Reviews for The Original Bella’s Pizzeria in Yukon, OK

We ordered a Stromboli, a pizza, and garlic knots. We hated all of the food. It appears, based on the online voting, that we... are in the minority here. The sauce had no signature. It was as bland as sauce could be. Before we knew about the flavorlesssauce, we had asked the sauce be baked into the Stromboli, otherwise they are too dry. The gracious lady behind the counterexplained, after the fact, that they don't do that because it's too messy. Well, turns out, the Stromboli was too dry aspredicted and seemed to have a powdery texture (too much flour perhaps?). The garlic knots were also flavorless and bland andtoo doughy - not as in undercooked but too much bread vs not enough garlic or butter. I will say the items were prepared andcooked well enough. The product just didn't fit our palate. Read more

Amazing experience at Bella's tonight. Customer service is top notch. We walked in, ordered and left within 15 mins, very speedy... service. They recommended the Mooney's which was good but the cheese bread was out of this world, hands down best we've had in along time. They do have a small dining area and lots of daily specials. Looking forward to coming back at trying more things. Read more

Best pizza around. And get this- I fed a family of 5 for $30 before tax- and had extra pizza left for breakfast the next... morning. Just ask about family specials. They?re a real bargain! Where else in town can you order out for 6$ per person? It?sa great deal on a great pizza! Read more

We are visiting from out of state and found this great little place! On their menu is an antipasta salad. In my little home... town, Pizza Mill, turned their antipasta salad into a pizza and it has become my all time favorite. So when I walked in and seean antipasta salad on Bella's menu I immediately asked if the chef could make it in to a pizza. He said yes!! Delicious! So ifyou are ever in Yukon stop at Bella's for a bite! Read more

The pizza was really good. The crust is the best part! Crust really makes the pizza to me.

We?ve heard of this place through word of mouth. We decided to give it a try and blown away by the size and flavor of the pizza.... The staff was just as amazing as the food. I highly recommend stopping by and giving them a chance it?s definitely worth it. Read more

This place is the best pizza place I?ve ever been to and not only because of how good their food is. They have committed so... many acts of kindness towards me and my family without even realizing how many times they have. The first instance was myfamily of three not having enough money for any groceries, we were all hungry and weren?t sure what to do. My mom posted onfacebook asking if anyone could help, and they gave us 2 FREE large pizzas, and 2 FREE 2L drinks. The second and thirdinstances were on halloween and the day after halloween. Me and my friends (8 of us) headed over to Bella?s for a pizza, we werefine with getting a X-large to share between us, but the guy working there said he loved our costumes so much, and he gave us 2X-large pizzas, a box of cheese sticks, 3 2L drinks, and even rearranged all of the tables to fit us for only $20. We came backthe next day with our costumes because halloween and trick or treating was still going on, and we had enough money this time,but they still gave us that exact same order for only $20 and said we didn?t need to pay full price just because our costumesmade their night. Keep in mind, they were very busy both of these nights, and still went out of their way to go over the top forus. The next instance was today, we ordered a pizza, got it home, and for me personally, it was too saucy. As crazy as itsounds, I get nauseous with too much sauce. We called in and asked if they were willing to make another one with light sauce,not only were they so apologetic (which they didn?t have to be) but they even offered us a full refund. They were so, so kind,when any other pizza place would?ve been pretty unkind about it. They are so insanely nice here at Bella?s, and they did all ofthis without even realized it?s been the same family with all of these acts of kindnesses. Their food is amazing, and theircustomer service is better than any place I have ever been to. - Photos of our me and my friends on halloween Read more

We didn?t expect to be this impressed when we gave Bella?s a try, but Bella?s exceeded our expectations. We had the jalapeño... poppers appetizer and it was very good. The pizzas were terrific! We ordered a large taco pizza and a large supreme pizza. Thetaco pizza might just be the most legitimate taco pizza of all time. They used refried beans and that with the other toppings,made this an amazing taco pizza. The supreme pizza had amazing flavor as well; the spices in the sausage and other meats had aslightly different flavor than the typical supreme pizzas elsewhere. The crust is a hand tossed New York Style crust and it wasperfect. Even Mrs. Flip Out commented that the crust had a really good flavor and texture, and she usually doesn?t comment onpizza crust. Come to find out, the owners/operators are NY transplants and they were very friendly and easy going. We lookforward to getting pizza from Bella?s again, either dining in or taking it home. Read more