Reviews for Jimmy John's in York, PA
I asked for you to add mayo on my sandwich when I ordered. That doesn't mean hand me packets of mayo. Food was sub par.
Absolutely the best sub shop in whole area. My wife and I love it so much that we travel 25 miles to get sub at Jimmy John's in... York. No other chain come close to taste of Jimmy John's French bread. And they are FAST. All the employees are very friendlyand courteous also. I wish someday Jimmy John's will open location in Gettysburg/Hanover area. Our favorites are Turkey subs andRoast Beef subs. You can't go wrong with either of them. Read more
Fellas working tonight made a great sandwich and was real quick with it. We?re very friendly and pleasant. Will be back again!
Good food prepared quickly. Easy to get in and out of and they deliver too, as well as cater. Pricey, as all Jimmy John's are,... and this last time I was there I had to bag my order myself, so that was a bit off-putting, which is why I have to dock them apoint. If you want a good sandwich, though, pay them a visit. Read more
First, I gave it two stars instead of one because I do love Jimmy John's overall. But the reality is this specific location... should only be 1 star. Every time I go there, something is wrong with the order. EVERY. SINGLE. TIME. Missing tomato, lettuce,and/or peppers; onions added when I asked for no onions; altogether wrong sandwiches. I've even ordered online a few times incase it was a miscommunication at the register, but I still have a bunch of errors with my order. The crazy part is we only make1-2 modifications from the standard sandwiches when we order, so it's not like we're asking for something highly customized. Read more
Albeit a few exits up the highway, this is the closest Jimmy John's to my house. Well worth the drive imo! Never had a bad... experience here, the crew is always friendly and polite, and they make amazing subs! Will keep returning for my Jimmy John's fixwhen that hunger calls, as it often does! Read more
Food was 5 stars but the front counter staff needs to listen to the orders We ordered 3 subs two without tomatoes and one with... cheese and guess what They werent made to our order and it is sad when you drive 30 minutes away to sit down with friends to eatyour sub and it was made wrong. I know it isnt that hard to pull out the tomatoes but it is the principal of it We added cheeseto the other when we got home So I hope someone will educate that customer orderes are important to customers Read more
Reasonably priced freaky fast subs