Reviews for Sheryl's Caribbean Cuisine (formerly Judy's Island Grill Tor in York, ON

It was great when it was Judy?s. Now the new owner took over and the food went down hill. The portion is less and the food is... not the greatest. I had ordered the Jerk chicken and was wondering why it was so small and taste so different. My friend hadtheir Ackee and Saltfish, taste rubberish and also smaller portion. Their curry shrimps was terrible also. I won?t be comingback. I hope this store takes this review and try to improve from it because you will be losing a lot more customers if youdon?t step your game up. Read more

About 5, 6 years ago, Judy?s jerk chicken pasta (when it was $10) was much much better quality than now (at $22). For the past 2... years every time I order it?s tasteless and DRENCHEDDD in oil it?s really upsetting to the stomach. I posted this review sohopefully they see it and fix it, you?re literally serving 80% oil and very tasteless pasta. Overall tho, Judy?s is amazingminus the pasta. I highly recommend the fried chicken and Mac salad. Read more

I brought my friend to get a soup. Red Pea Soup, BEEF. HOW AWFUL. ONLY RED PEAS IRISH POTATO, ONE DUMPLINGPP MEAT NADA. How can... one support these black own business. VERY DISAPPOINTED. THE SERVER NEEDS KNOW. Read more

Meet Sheryl, female chef and owner of Judy?s. Sheryl and her whole team are so welcoming. You walk into her spot and there is... the most delicious hot table filled with scratch made Jamaican food. There are also the most delicious home made juices. You canget great jerk but also the best juiciest shrimp. Her sweet potato pudding is a must. Check out the bbq chicken as somethingdifferent and greens are always the best. Please follow @joannasable on instagram Read more

Food was good, we had BBQ chicken, fried chicken, and ox tail. Only complaint was The fried chicken wasn't served hot - it was... barely warm. Rice and peas were okay. Read more

We order Goat curry, Bbq Chicken and Oxtails. All was very good and a bit spicy. Will order again.

After finding Judy's on a food delivery app I wasn't sure what to order so I went to their establishment. This was truely... helpful as the staff provided informative suggestions that proved to be excellent. We got some ox tails and jerk chicken. Therice and peas was excellent with a simple salad. This was our first exposure to Jamaican food and think it was nice start. Read more

Fast and tasty. Want to eat it all at once but have enough for 2nd/3rd meal to enjoy again. Happy to support this local... business. Read more