Reviews for Peter's New York Pizzeria in Wolcott, NY
Great food and customer service is wonderful. Went in late on a Sunday from a neighboring town since the local pizza place was... closed already and loved the friendly service. Read more
Came into restaurant based on others reviews on a little day with family. Could not have been happier. Food was great, service... amazing. We will be back anytime in the area. Read more
Honestly some of the best garlic knots I've ever had, you can tell these guys know how to make New York style pizza and sides,... wings were nice and crispy and the big guy at the counter made you feel like you where in Brooklyn, great place, I will be back! Read more
A hidden gem! I'm sure not sure I've had a better slice in NYC proper!
This place makes an impressive pizza. I ordered a sheet for a Birthday/Father's Day party. Everyone was very complimentary.... Fresh ingredients. Delicious sauce. This was our 2nd time ordering from Peter's but it most certainly will not be our last.Thank you for the food obviously made with love and dedication. Amy W. Read more
Quaint place on Main Street. The pizza was FANTASTIC. The staff was friendly and patient while we decided what toppings we... desired. Don?t miss this place. Read more
The pizza was absolutely amazing!!!!! Drove from Walworth about 45 minutes from you guys because I had heard some good things... and man you didn't disappoint. As soon as I walked in and was greeted with that beautiful Brooklyn accent I knew it was going tobe good but man I was not prepared for just how good it was will definitely be returning again soon because I'm already hookedfor more! Keep up the great work! Read more
susie pizza tonight was amazing. the service was excellent and they were very friendly, talkative, and welcoming. the food was... absolutely delightful!! best pizza in Wolcott. i would recommend this establishment to anyone, you?ll have a great mood afteryou visit! Read more