Reviews for Paellas Restaurant in Winter Park, CO

Paellas Restaurant is amazing. Small selection but high quality entrees and taipas too. We had assortment appetizer, lamb chops,... sea bass filet and flan. All the best eats. My flan conisour gave that desert 2 thumbs up. We read the other reviews and hadnon bottled water so our bill was reasonable. Just ask for tap water. Read more

Paellas is more than just great food. It is a great experience. The atmosphere and service was exceptional. I came in a stranger... and walked out saying goodbye to new friends. Chef / owner is a delightful person. His culinary experience shines in everybite. Everything was cooked to perfection and had incredible flavor. Thank you for a wonderful evening! Read more

What an incredible experience! Thank you Neil and your wonderful team. It feels like your dining at secret Spanish hideaway in... Winter Park. A family owned gem. Tasty food and delicious cocktails. EVERYTHING IS SO YUMMY. Hospitality was on point and thecozy patio in summertime was a great vibe! Read more

This is definitely 5 stars.The food and service here are fantastic and the drinks are fantastic too! The ambiance is romantic... and comfortable. I took my wife for our anniversary. I started with a Margarita and my wife had a Spanish drink calledCaipirina. Both were great. They bring warm bread with olive oil and pepper and a bowl of olives in olive oil. I had the mostamazing Chilean Sea Bass and my wife had the Paella de Mariscos. We both loved our dishes. The Sea Bass was buttery and cookedto perfection. We then had a Pina Colorado which was delicious and the fresh mint blended in the drink was delicious. The Chefcame by to check on us and also offered a shot on the house of a Spanish liquor that tasted spicy and warm. We finished withFlan which was hearty and delicious. Our waiter was excellent and the entire staff was very helpful. We had a great experience!Highly recommend! Read more

My husband and I loved this restaurant. They were fairly busy when we went but we were seated immediately and attended to. Our... food came out within minutes, exceptionally fast. And the staff is so nice and really make you feel important. We were treatedlike VIPs. We love to try new places when traveling and we have never had better service anywhere. It was phenomenal. On to thefood: also amazingly good and authentic Spanish cuisine. We had the ceviche which was so delicious and probably our favorite. Wealso got the scallops appetizer and it was very fresh and tasty. For our main course, my husband and I shared the Lomito Paella,which is angus tenderloins with rice and asparagus. It was cooked to perfection, exactly how we requested. We had the flan fordesert but I forgot to get a picture because we ate it so fast. Hands down would recommend eating here when in or near WinterPark. You won?t regret it. For our 2 appetizers, 2 cocktails, and main course our bill was around $115, which is also very wellpriced for what you get. Update: we ate here 3 nights in a row. The food is so good and service so excellent that we didn?twant to eat anywhere else. We got the lamb chops twice and it is heaven on a plate. We also got the other steak meal (withpotatoes and fried leeks) at the recommendation of our server and thought it was excellent. Read more

Yes, it's a five out of five for sure! Both our appetizers and main courses are just delicious, so are the drinks. We tried... seared scallops - made me drooling just by smelling it, sweet and tender; toasted bread with tomato sauce and balsamic vinegar -crispy and appetizing; seabass with truffle - perfect sear, fresh and juicy; seafood paelle - surprising amount of seafood,aromatic and fulfilling. Oh, and the sangria, such rich fruity flavor, loved it! A must try if you are in Winter Park. Read more

The best place to eat in Winter Park! The Chilean sea bass with black truffles, saffron rice, and grilled asparagus was perfect!... Not one thing needs to be changed. The service was impeccable. Attentive but not hovering. We ate in the outdoor seating areaand it was so relaxing we hated to leave. I cannot recommend Paellas enough! Read more

This wins the best meal of the month award for being decadent and everything perfectly paired with our dishes. The chef is very... humble and came out to meet us and tell us about Spanish cuisine. Presentation is top notch! Don?t expect a big paella skilletbut do expect subtle dish cooked to perfection. Expect to pay in the $$ range but it?s well worth it! Read more