Reviews for Captain Tony's Pizza in Winslow, AZ

Very unique little spot. We drive OTR and try to find small non chain type places. Wasn't busy when we arrived. Cashier was... taking a phone order but she acknowledged our presence. Prices are reasonable. Personal pan pizza plus one trip to salad bar wasplenty for me. Very tasty crust. Definitely will stop by again when we're in the area. Read more

Wow! This place is wretched, gnarly! ???????????? For those that don?t know, that?s my way of saying they have some tasty `zza... ???? hand tossed AND thin crust! Don?t forget they have a retro arcade and pool tables! The nostalgia factor isintense! Sioux City soda to top it all off. I will definitely make this a favorite place to stop and get a bite toeat. Thanks Cpt. Tony! ???? Read more

More-than-outstanding!! Every time I?ve ordered, the pizza is spot on. Whether it?s carry out or dine-in, I?ve been a happy... customer. Whichever pie, the ingredients are fresh and it?s cooked to my liking. Never too oily, never too salty. Rae (not sureof spelling) is always there with a smile. Excellent service! Read more

The only complaint I could have with this place is that I am totally missing their amazing full buffet they had before covid... shook up the country. They are absolutely professional, fuendly and the food is always great. Today I'm taking out rather thanstaying but have had numerous experiences with dine in and take out and always totally satisfied. Please bring the full buffetback soon. Got the works.. salad, pizza ,garlic bread and wings Read more

Had the lasagna and it was great, salad bar was stocked with a lot of items.

Truckers get 10% off on their food and with meal you get free drink. The food was awesome and so were the cashier. I had cheese... steak sub it was mouth watering smelled delicious. They had buffet also Read more

Stopping through town to see the flatbed Ford discovered this Gem of a pizza shop called Captain Tony's, The original... hand-tossed crust is unbelievable. is so light holds up well to the sauce and the cheese is abundant. Baked to perfection with alight Golden crust. The tomato sauce even taste homemade. If you're in Arizona on 40 you need to stop here. Read more

Took my granddaughter here to play arcades. They close off all arcades for a private party so no arcades for the kids. The... boneless wings were like chicken nuggets w sauce. Yuck, I couldn't eat this. The pizza was okay but they only give 3 packets ofparmesean cheese. We waited a very long time for our food. We will NOT be back. Read more