Reviews for Agostino's Pizzeria in Winnipeg, MB

Great meatlover's pizza and Greek salad! They even gave me a second pizza free because the skip the dishes driver was late due... to car trouble Read more

I wish 1-star was possible. This place is awful. Crust is frozen, cheese is minimal, sauce was straight from a can, pepperoni's... had absolutely no flavor. Garlic toast was Texas toast with about a half teaspoon of cheap imitation butter. Alfredo was 3/10,definitely not homemade as advertised. Don't waste a dollar here.... Read more

This was at one time Winnipeg?s best pizza but holy smokes what garbage the crust is different it taste frozen and the toppings... are minimal and taste like cheap toppings pizza is pure garbage the days of homemade sausage are gone no extra sauce on top ofpizza barely any cheese. It?s a shame a once proud family owned restaurant that had awesome pizza and fantastic sides is nowgarbage, it?s worse than pizza from 7/11, it?s horrible don?t waste your hard earned money, and of the old owners read this plzopen up another pizza restaurant. Zero stars is to good for this place and on top of that you pay for delivery and pizza was 45mins late and was stone cold, dogs didn?t not want to eat it, thanks to Santa Lucia they saved the day with awesome pizza forpretty much the same price with fantastic sauce lots of topping and cheese hot and fresh and free delivery. Read more

I always order pizza it was great food. Until I ordered extra bbq sauce. The first pizza barely had any so I called the second... pizza was so heavy and black with bbq sauce. It was disgusting and went in the garbage. Never going to order again. $50.00 for 2pizzas what a waste of money. Read more

The staff are always very kind and approachable. Food is also amazing. The portion of their calzone is huge and very juicy... inside. Pizza wise, the Agostinos and Mamma Deluxe are my favorite so I would highly recommend it to first time customers. Theribs are surprisingly good as well and fall off the bone. Overall, Im very hapoy with this family owned pizza place. Letssupport local businesses ???? Read more

Was Great pizza always friendly, we went tonight and got this I feel like I feel like the quality is lacking, this is double... cheese... Read more

I?ve ordered from Agostino?s Pizzeria a bunch of times and the pizza is pretty good. It?s slightly cheaper than Santa Lucia but... in the same ballpark when you compare equivalent pizza sizes. The pizzas at Agostino?s are pretty fresh and flavorful. Igenerally go for delivery. I have picked up the pizzas before in person and they have this weird payment system where it?sconfusing and pushes you to add a tip even though you?re picking it up yourself (and it?s tricky to opt out of it). In somecases, I just added a tip when picking it up because I was caught off guard and confused (why tip for pickup??), and then laterlaughed at myself because? well, I paid more to pick it up when you include the tip than if I had it delivered. Lol. I know alot of businesses have this newer practice ? pushing customers into adding tips whenever you can to you add fifteen percent tomaximize profits. So, I get that this restaurant isn?t alone in this practice, but it is certainly off-putting and wildlyannoying. And, as a result, I don?t order from here very often because of frustrations as noted above. Read more

Go early fresh is best but I?ve been after 1:00 and still have had great slices. They serve Pepsi selections. Have their pizza... delivered it?s very good. Read more