Reviews for Windsor Brick Oven Pizza in Windsor, CO

Would give a zero star if possible. We ordered a supreme with only half sausage because my wife doesn't eat sausage but the... pizza we received was ALL SAUSAGE. ALSO ZERO VEG ON A SUPREME WHICH IS WEIRD. We brought the pizza back to them untouched andthey claimed "it is ground beef" but I tasted it and it was NOT ground beef. We asked for a remake/refund and the kid behindthe counter was more interested in the girl chatting him up than taking care of this issue. We asked for a refund BEFORE 9pm(closing time) but he "couldn't do it because he already closed the tills for the night" at 845pm... I was then stuck with apizza that was undercooked, incorrect and could not be eaten. HORRIBLE service and pizza. I will not be back no matter what youoffer me. I refused the charge through my bank and you all need to reevaluate your staff. Read more

I tried to order a large pizza, $22.50, for delivery less than two miles away. Was told after tax it would be $29. After... inquiring why the price jump, I was told there's a "delivery fee" added on, which I was told they do NOT give to the driver,who, they confirmed, drive their own vehicle. I understand the need to cover costs in this circumstances, and I strive to shoplocal, but a $5.25 fee they tack on for themselves, not even for a guaranteed tip for the driver, is super shady. Will not beordering from them again. Read more

Worst experience and pizza. Some one should supervise the teens that work there or close shop? update pizza, cheese bread, and... calzone was bland and tasteless. Marinara sauce was watered down. Read more

!WoW!???? ???? ???????????? Ok Iam very picky with my food especially with pizza. Great job

Stopped in on a whim, got there before they had any slices out. Ordered a whole pie and was shocked, the crust is fresh buttery... and crispy, the jalapenos were fresh, the sauce is amazing. Totally exceeded my expectation walking in. Side note has alltopping except for my favorite to go with jalapeno- cream cheese! Definitely stop in. Read more

My wife and I decided to randomly go have pizza with our son here, and let me say, in my opinion, this was by far the best pizza... in Windsor. The staff was super friendly, the pizza was cooked perfectly, the cinnamon sticks were so good, I just wanted tokeep eating them lol. Honestly, I can't wait to go again, awesome experience <3 Read more

I have had pizza in close to 50 countries. This is one of the best pizzas I have ever had!! They are extremely generous with the... cheese and I didn't even have to ask for extra cheese. The cheese is delicious!! The sauce is really good too and has a hint ofgarlic in it. The dough is also really good. I was super impressed with this pizza place! My family also loved the bbq chickenpizza! We will definitely be back!! We moved from Germany a few months ago and this is the best pizza we have had since movingto Colorado! Also they were very friendly and the service was great too! Read more

We've ordered from here twice but won't order again. The pizza was okay, nothing to rave about. The cinnamon sticks were too... thin, a little burnt, and tough to pull apart when biting. The second time we decided to try a Stromboli. It was so greasy thatit was dripping. The bottom was burnt. We ordered a side of Alfredo sauce for dipping and it tasted exactly like Bertolli's fromthe jar. We also ordered a salad which was brown, shredded lettuce with way more toppings than lettuce (chopped green peppers,olives, raw white or yellow onion, mushrooms, and shredded mozzarella). We didn't even eat it so that was a waste of $6.50. Thedressings are in packets and the ranch is so sour. We wanted to support local and tried to like it, but it's just not good,unfortunately. Read more