Reviews for Newberry Sub Shop in Williamsport, PA
Took over 40 minutes to get 1/2 cheesesteak and 1 regular hoagie. The hoagie had VERY minimal lettuce, tomato, and onion. Did... not look like the hoagies they show on their Facebook page. Have been wanting to go there for awhile and I was verydisappointed. Read more
Ordered large (whole) sausage and 1/2 cheese steak was charged $26 there food is good but not that good.
Was eating there like a decade ago because my AGM always got it for dinner pay week. Just got hungry for dinner and thought of... subs a decade later and thought of them. Good food, big sandwich and great price as always. Will be back even if I have beengone for a decade when I come back definitely stop for their cheese steak. Read more
We went on a recommendation from a plant we were visiting in town (wscc). It was a brilliant recommendation! I'm not the expert... on cheesesteaks and actively avoid most things Philly, but this cheesesteak was amazing and huge! You'll wait a minute, bepatient, it's worth the wait 100%. Thanks!! Read more
Excellent subs with friendly staff!! Unfortunately I went 3 times on my trip to the area and ordered subs that were supposed to... be toasted. The first time I was told you have to order it cosmo so on my second trip I did order a ham cosmo, it was excellentand the roll was toasted perfectly, but the third trip didn't end as well. I ordered a cheesesteak cosmo and they didn't toastthe roll, but they wrapped it in foil not sure how that helps! Read more
This local, family run sub shop is a hidden gem! The two ladies in there, were extremely friendly and appreciated my family... coming to dine with them! The sandwiches and wraps were large and delicious. The bread was freshly made and you could tell withthe first bite. This is a must for a quick bite. Will definitely be visiting again! Read more
Always a great idea to go to Newberry Subs! Ham & cheese Cosmo hits it! Friendly hard working staff is all you can want in a... Pennsylvania neighborhood! Read more
Great FRIENDLY service! Atmosphere is vintage in a good way but a little small. Food was decent at best.