Reviews for Peppinos Italian Eatery in Williamson, NY

We recently moved to the area on search for even one quality restaurant. Decided to give Peppinos a try and boy, we were so... excited. Everything on this menu is fantastic and the chef and staff are there to make your experience a five star. Myfavorite… artichokes French! Don’t be afraid to ask for variations, the chef is more than happy to accommodate! We’ll beback! Read more

What a pleasant surprise! A cute little restaurant, which is clean and bright. The server was very professional and pleasant.... The food was very tasty… seasonings and flavors were unique. I would eat there again! Read more

This is no way a real Italian restaurant. The chicken and rice soup the other day was extremely overbearing with oregano... flavoring. I lived in the big city and stopped in Little Italy thousands of times. Real Italian cooks seldom and lightly useoregano because of it\'s strength of flavor. Veal Marsala had absolutely no wine flavor in the sauce and the veal was very overcooked. Shrimp Scampi was tasteless and needed a proper amount of sauteed onions and garlic with parsley to top it. Bread wasdecent, but as for the butter spread, was again very overwhelming with an odd oily taste. This restaurant is one that has nohints of a true Italian Cuisine. There\'s no return visit here. My 64 year-old fiance who\'s Sicilian and from Brooklyn clearlyestablished that the meals we had wasn\'t in any way shape or form of Italian. Yes I would find a different place if I want tohave an Italian restaurant dinner. Read more

It was the first time we ate here. The staff was exceptional, friendly, quick service, and the restaurant was clean, comfortable... and nicely decorated. The food was mouth watering, seafood bisque was the best I\'ve tasted around here. The pasta dishes werevery yummy and plenty of food for another meal. We will definitely be back to this gem of a restaurant in our area! Read more

What a great Italian place to eat! Good food & good prices! Drove by it a few times.. it\'s a little on the small side but we... decided to give it a try last week. I had the gnocchis w/ greens, beans & sausage.. amazing! It\'s a large portion, got a couplemeals out of it! So good! Wife got 3 big cheese raviolis, she loved hers as well. Definitely stopping back in again soon! Read more

The service was great and and everyone in my party enjoyed their food. The pasta was cooked to perfection and the chicken for my... Marsala was nice and thin and tender and moist. I also want to say thanks for being so accommodating because I can’t havedairy and our waitress checked with the chef to make sure I remained dairy free. Read more

My wife and I stopped in tonight after hearing positive reviews from relatives. I had the chicken cacciatore and the wife had... the chicken Florentine and both were delicious except there was to much salt in both dishes. We also had the cream of mushroomsoup and that was salty also. Read more

Food was amazing!! This was the best chicken marsala I have ever had, and I\'ve tried it at all the restaurants. My daughter had... chicken French which was delicious. I cat wait to go back. Read more