Reviews for Theodora's Family Restaurant and Pizza in Wharton, NJ

Great food and friendly service from wait staff and owner. The bread rolls are large and fantastic. It was hard to not eat the... whole thing to save room for the entree. Read more

What?s the point of offering delivery when every order takes 2 hours to arrive and food is barely edible and you?re only 10... minutes away ? Then they send wrong order and you wait another hour and now your $50 meal is ready for the trash , got it. Surethe guy with the heavy accent would be just dying to tell you how he doesn?t need your business as usual. Avoid this place, wentdown hill quickly Read more

What I love about Theodora?s is that they are always consistent?other places around here are good but the pizza is hit or miss... (maybe someone?s day off?) or they mess up my order constantly. That has never happened to me at Theodora?s. The pizza, thesalads, the sandwiches, the dinners are prepared not only consistent but delicious. You can tell the family loves their placeand takes pride in their food and serving their patrons. Read more

Authentic Greek restaurant at its finest. Chicken souvlaki and Greek fries were a 10 out of 10! Def coming back here!

My husband and I just heard about this restaurant and we decided to go recently. They have an Italian menu and a Greek menu. ... Knowing this, we went to experience their Greek food. Growing up with my Greek friend I am very familiar with amazing Greekfood. Well let me tell you, Theodora's did not disappoint. My husband had the Greek lasagna, Pastitsio and I had thespanakopita with the filo dough, spinach and feta cheese and both dishes could not have been more authentic. We also tried thebaklava dessert, very very good. Prices were great as well. We will definitely be back! Read more

We really really wanted to give this place five stars. It has great ratings and we were from out of the area meeting with... friends and we're hoping that this would be a slam dunk. They had a sat right away but it took forever to get service. They hadone server with 12 tables and a bus girl. We felt so horrible for the waitress as she was running around like a maniac. The airconditioning must have been broken. The food was delicious when we got it but it was an hour later before we got basic pastadishes. We will be back and we will try it again but I hope they fix their problems Read more

Please avoid at all costs. I have gone to them several times and their service has usually been excellent. However, I ordered a... simple case of 6 fried Oreos today. I have had them several times in the past and they tasted just fine. Today, however, theytasted solely of the peanut oil they are fried in. You cannot chew and swallow them before the taste of the burnt oil comesthrough so sharply and makes you want to gag. It was horrendous. I cannot tell you how awful these were compared to the pasttimes I have had them. I called the restaurant politely and spoke with an Italian man and explained the situation. Heinterrupted me several times, explained this cannot be the case since I am the first man to complain of these awful taste, saidif you don?t like them you can go elsewhere, and told me to screw off and hung up the phone. I have given them my business forseveral years as a local in the area, but their rude, inconsiderate, mocking, and inhospitable customer service has turned meaway from them forever. I do not write any of this lightly or in jest. If they do not know how to speak with customers politelyand listen, I ensure you they do not care about the quality of the food they serve you. Look elsewhere for food in Wharton andbeyond. I promise you will not miss anything by avoiding this restaurant ran by mean-spirited bullies. Lastly, do not takeanything to heart they may say in their comment to this message. They will claim I?m being selfish. I ensure I have nothing to Igain here but to provide you some wisdom from choosing a better place to give your hard-earned money and time. Read more

Talk about a fun local eatery with all your italian and greek favorites!! Theodora's was accommodating for our table of 7... reservation and they were so sweet to us the whole time. It was clean and the food was delicious as well! BYOB if you would liketo bring your wine or beer and i highly recommend the fried calamari to start! The bread is also amazing and brought outindividually so one bread per person ???? Read more