Reviews for Sandman Gourmet Pizza in Westerville, OH

Great Pizza Great Salads Great Staff!!! By far my NEW FAVE

Ordered last night and was excited to try it out. Ordered Wings and two pizza's, 1/2 Cheese and 1/2 Pepperoni and a Buffalo... Chicken Pizza. Got home with it and realized they gave a Pepperoni and not Buffalo Chicken. Called up there and both times wastold getting a manager and left me on hold for 15 minutes. Was not real happy about that, and didn't feel like driving all theway back to figure it out with that treatment. Wings were really good, could taste the apple chips with the Buffalo. Realgood. Pizza was ok, not as great as I had hoped but still wonder if the specialty pizza would have been good. Not sure I willever find out based on the service we got. Read more

Walked in and grabbed a Caesar salad (they made it on the spot) and 2 slices for lunch. The pepperoni pizza was very good! The... 2nd slice I tried the chicken Philly, very flavorful and I wish I could have bottled up that amazing smell so I could haveenjoyed it longer than the pizza lasted! For a quick grab and go lunch I would definitely recommend this hidden gem. We will betrying the delivery service out in the near future! Staff was friendly when I called to ask about the lunch special and when Iarrived they were equally as helpful and friendly! I can?t wait to come back and try something else! Read more

I was skeptical to order from what I thought was an office cafeteria but I will be back! The pork sandwich was amazing, huge,... and a great value. It brings me back to the days when Sandman made the best cheesesteaks downtown. I can't wait to try otheritems. Read more

Sandman Pizza did a wonderful job with the catering for my husband?s birthday party. The Pulled Pork and Macaroni and Cheese... were delicious and a hit with our guests! Catering Manager Suzy was responsive and so helpful! I highly recommend for your nextevent. Read more

Outstanding pizza!!!! I had never seen this restaurant before because it is a little hidden. But am so glad I found them because... I loved the pizza. Some things I haven?t seen at your standard pizza joint. The carmelized shallot and garlic made my pizzareally pop. And saw this big grill out front and can?t wait to try the wings. Shout out to Susie who was so friendly and nice.Can?t wait to come back! Read more

We ordered the ode to the magnificent mushroom pizza. It was wonderful! Quality ingredients really elevate their pizza over... competitors. There was a minor issue with the timing of our order, but the manager more than made up for it. It's well worthgiving them a try. Read more

YUM!!!!!! This is my new favorite Pizza in Columbus. Super nice staff and the food is phenomenal. We had the Magnificent... Mushroom pizza and it was named correctly. I only wish it was closer to my house. You gotta try this place. Read more