Reviews for Just Pies Inc in Westerville, OH
Try anything. You really can't go wrong honestly. Well, unless you have an allergy to something but that's a different... matter. If you want recommendations, the cherry crumble or anything fruit. Or something complicated if you make fruit piesregularly. Read more
Elderly mother of a friend was brought to tears over the butterscotch pie?said it was just as her mother made it. I have bought... over 100 pies here and not one was wrong. Best. Pies. Ever. Read more
Key lime pie was delicious! I would have enjoyed a stronger lime flavor. The meringue was creamy and perfect.
A friend got me a peach pie. I love peach pie! This was nothing special. Buy a frozen pie at Kroger and bake it yourself. Sure... doesn?t taste homemade. Disappointing for sure. Wouldn?t go back for seconds. Read more
I live their Strawberry Pies but that made one un the month of June which was a Peach Cream Pie and is my best flavor but they... don't have it anymore. I pray they will bring that back real soon I love that one the best, so please bring that one back. Read more
Got 3 pies for Thanksgiving (Pumpkin, Pecan & Apple Crumb) and all were great. Today (12/1), I was responsible for dessert and... got there at 5:05pm. Closed at 5pm, doors locked and the two employees had coats in hand about to walk out as I walked up. Theyoung lady with grey hair unlocked the door, while the other young woman packed a pie for me. The pie was for just me and mywife, but I bought the large and two batches of cookies just to support such a wonderful business. Got the Triple Berry. YUM.Thank you Just Pies! Read more
This place is awesome! First time here and we will definitely be returning. All of the pies we purchased tasted excellent, the... service was courteous and friendly. They are doing a good job with their layout to keep customers safe and comfortable! Didn'tget a picture but we also got a 10" Beef pie and a 10" Broccoli and cheese. They come frozen and you bake them at home. Wepopped the beef one in the oven as soon as we got home, convection oven, 90 minutes, set for another 15 minutes and thendevoured! Delicious and no dinner prep that night! Read more
Easily the best pies I've ever had in my life. Make sure you go very early the day before Thanksgiving or be prepared to get... what you get. Read more