Reviews for Graeter's Ice Cream in Westerville, OH
We were just there for 4th Friday and waited in line from the sidewalk to get my girls ice cream. Once we made it to the... counter and were a second from ordering, one gal said we couldn't order because I had a Dora drink in my hand. I asked if Icould just buy my kids ice cream and leave and she said no. So I left with very disappointed children on a popular nightdespite that we are there every week. Know your audience on this night!! Read more
Ice cream is great! Staff is rude and unfriendly. Busy talking to each other as we were ordering and messed up my husbands... order. We mentioned it and they didn?t seem to really care. Read more
Terra was excellent and the Elena?s Blueberry Pie was excellent!!! Go Cone For The Cure!!
Very nice staff and fast service, great ice cream!
They went above and beyond for me with COVID going on. I needed some light blue jelly beans and they were able to get them from... the back and deliver for a 4yr olds birthday party! They were great!!! Read more
Always have the friendliest staff and the best ice cream around. They are always putting out special limited edition flavors... that are fantastic. My in laws always take some back with them to NY. Read more
For me, Graeter's is what I compare all other ice creams against. I have not had a bad flavor yet, but some are certainly better... than others. Fortunately if you're unsure, they'll give you a baby spoon sample so you don't end up regretting your choice. Itis a little pricey compared to other places, but the selection is great. The mocha chip is my go-to, end all be all, ride or dieflavor of choice. I have yet to find another flavor anywhere to match. Some of the employees are a little heavier handed thanothers so needles to say my heart feels heavy when the cone does not. Recently I broke away from the mold and sampled the cheesecrown. Don't let the name fool you, it is the Cadillac of cheesecake ice cream. It's as though someone dropped a cheesecake intothe mixer and threw in some sweet frosting for good measure. You can't go wrong with Vanilla (or any flavor) as it just reliablygood. You pair that with a chocolate dipped waffle cone and you will take your taste buds to new places. Do yourself a favor andjust get two scoops. Read more
Have been here a few times, good ice cream generally. Most recent experience was superb, the gentleman helping us was also... trying to serve a family of 7-ish with multiple kids who all wanted samples and he handled it like a champ and the smile nevercame off his face (not something I could have done). I wish I had checked his name. Read more