Reviews for Rusty Nickel Brewing Co. in West Seneca, NY
This is the best hidden gem in the neighborhood. We just had my daughter’s bridal shower at Rusty Nickel & it was beautiful!... Everyone said how great the food was, which was provided by Carmen’s Catering. Best Bridal Shower ever!!! Thank you RustyNickel for helping me make that possible. Kudos to Janene! Read more
We hosted a wedding reception for our daughter & her husband in the outdoor area of this venue. My daughter was very happy with... the rustic atmosphere, the open areas, the easy access to food tables and the friendly & helpful staff. We decorated with masonjars and flowers. Everything was lovely. Emily, the event planner, was helpful & knowledgeable throughout the process. Ourfriends & relatives all had a great afternoon celebrating, and we the family, also had a wonderful, stress free event. Myheartfelt thanks to the employees who seemed to effortlessly create a carefree, downhome atmosphere for us to enjoy the day.Highly recommend for any event. Read more
Loved this place such good beers. Amazing outdoor seating area. The inside of the building could be cooler it was so hot in... there and waiting in line for a while feeling that uncomfortable was not so great but other than that was a great atmosphere Read more
First time coming here after work on a Wednesday, the atmosphere is calm and relaxing, the beer was SO GOOD. and the service was... lovely! My new favorite brewing company and bar! Read more
Rustic and relaxing. Great music in the background. Nice outdoor space. Decent selection of beers / ciders. Mixed drink... options. Friendly staff. Food was basic, but hit the spot. The cinnamon, caramel pretzel was a nice combination (desert). Worthy if a stop! . Some of the table (old spools) are too tall for the chairs being used. Was a little awkward to me. Butthat's being picky. Would give a 4.5 if an option... Update 061922:. We return to Rusty Nickel to celebrate Father's Day. Youwere the first ones to arrive and we're a little disappointed to see some of the brews we had planned to try being out and/or akeg could not be found. It seemed like they were short staffed initially. The grounds still remain pleasant and relaxing. Wasn'ttoo busy. Plenty of outdoor seating on the patio. The food this time was fair, some menu items were not available and some wereremoved since our last visit. May have just been an off day. Will give it a try another day. Would downgrade to three stars thistrip. Read more
Really late in getting around to this review: Came here on a whim and accidentally showed up on their anniversary party. The... location is great and the outdoor section in the back is beautiful. The staff was super friendly and took time to talk toeveryone at the bar despite how busy it was. The beer was decent but I only tried a few so I'll need to go back again becausethey have a pretty healthy selection of beers to try. Read more
Great atmosphere and a large selection of drinks! We came at around 8:30 and there was a musician singing outside. I had a... "Honey Nut Beerios" which was pretty good. It was a little hoppy than what I'm used to. They also serve some food. Read more
I’ve been here several times and have enjoyed each time. This is a very small boutique brewery, so spending time here always... feels very intimate and homey. There is a nice selection of beer and wine, and for cider drinkers like myself there are usually2-3 options which is a refreshing surprise from some breweries. There is a huge outdoor space with a covered patio which isgreat for outdoor drinks all year long thanks to the heaters in the roof. The downside is always parking as the lot is nothuge. I would recommend getting here earlier in the evening to make sure you get a spot. Read more