Reviews for Hot Pie Pizza in West Palm Beach, FL

I wish I had the opportunity to even try the pizza. On November 17, 2022, I came to the establishment at 1:30 to place a take... out order, to bring back to the office. The doors were propped open, music playing, and the television was on. I asked if Icould place a "to go" order, and I was met with an abrasive, "WE'RE CLOSED! We open tomorrow at 11am." I do understand that thislocation has a "siesta" (given that I've attended high school in Italy) that begins at 2pm, but I don't find it completelyunreasonable that a take out order can't be facilitated within a 30-minute time span. Even then, to place the directive to "tryagain" the next day, as opposed to offering the option of returning when they reopen at 5 pm, was rather rude. I didn't want tolabel this encounter as a racist one, so I'll lend it to being the overall culture of the location. Maybe it's divineintervention that I didn't patron this business. I recommend others not either. Read more

Definitely do not recommend this restaurant, me and my family used to come to this place kind of often but after how terrible we... were treated last night by an asian looking manager Marcia, she asked us to move to another table while we were in the middle ofeating dinner with my wife, son (4) and infant daughter (1) just because a bar customer was complaining of my 1 year old makingsome noise just like any other normal infant would make. She made a big argument about it and even the family next to us couldnot believe her reaction to it and the gentleman in that table had also another argument with her trying to defend us. To backher off I told her if she want us to leave we would but we would not paid for the food and she even said she would call thepolice if we didnt pay for the food. I asked Sophie the waitress for the check, paid and left. It was a horrible experience formy family, she ruined our night. Definitely not a family restaurant. Read more

After a Dave Portnoy pizza review, I gave this place a chance (he rated it fairly high). The pizza was mediocre and the cheese... didn?t even stick to the tomato sauce. Read more

True NY Coal Fire. Been eating here for years. One of my favorite places to grab authentic New York style pizza. You can sit... inside or outside. Always great service. We ordered the cheese bread appetizer and it fat five of us. The pizza was the hot pie. Delicious all the way. Everyone loved it. About 200 years from clematis street. Read more

Ordered the New Yorker pizza and garlic bread for takeout that we brought to the beach. It was ready after 20 minutes, the... restaurant was clean and had outdoor dining as well as a nice large bar that had several people at it. Pizza was amazing andstill hot. Garlic bread came with two marinara dips and was a huge portion. Would order from here again. Thank you! Read more

Best pizza and atmosphere in West Palm Beach! They have a full bar too.

Insanely good. The tomato sauce was bursting with flavor. Not normally a fan of oven baked wings but wow, definitely returning... here on a regular basis. Read more

John from Jersey, is the most dedicated and talented Restaurant Owner I've Ever Known !! ALL ingredients, the best !! the SALADS... !! you will be AMAZED ! OF COURSE PIZZA THE BEST !! Like you were back up North, ok ?? It's the kind where you don't leave thecrust , ok ?? DONT tell your friends !! Less crowded when YOU go !! Read more