Reviews for Our Little Italy Pizza & Pasta in West Islip, NY

The food is top notch. As with many places now they charge a fee for cashless payments. I don?t agree with it.

Was in the area & was starving so I decided to give this place a try. Located in a smal shopping center off union blvd. Very... nice inside . I got a Buffalo chicken slice which was okay. I didn?t like that they put onions on it. Gave the slice a weirdtexture . White slice was very good , each bite was crispy & hot. Pretty fast service as well. I?d go back, they have a lot ofoptions for slices Read more

The food here isn't bad. Ambiance could be much much better especially for a family oriented restaurant/pizza shop. Yankees and... Mets both having great seasons with a game on every day yet me or my group is forced to watch Tucker Carlson looking down uponus from the big screen TV every time I try to enjoy a meal there like Big Brother. Hope this helps! Let's go Yanks! Read more

Excellent service and great food I could give them 7 star keep going with the great work

Ordered $40+ of takeout last night & got home to eat with the Sicilian pizza dough was literally raw. Called and they offered to... refund the two slices and give us a gift card?. Big whoop. Manager or owner I spoke to seemed to know it happened, must have hadothers complain. Wont ever order again. Read more

The best pizza place on Long Island! All the food is fresh and delicious, the taco slice from there is gigantic ,made fresh... every time & is amazing! Read more

Delicious!!! Got the margarita pizza and meatballs which are both now new favorites for me ???? Got it delivered and it came 15... minutes earlier than expected! Will definitely be getting it again. Read more

Good Service + Good food = Great experience! We had pasta w/ garlic (triple dose), spinach and pasta with sausage. We loved... it. The staff was VERY attentive. Read more