Reviews for Cafe Europa Pizzeria & Restaurant in West Islip, NY

Pizza is amazing but don?t even try going through slice when ordering. They need to not try and force you to use the app. They... closed before my order came. Even spoke to them on the phone because the app wouldn?t let me fix my order, so they clearly hadmy order. It said out for delivery yet nothing. Had to cook my own dinner at 9:30 after waiting on an order just to find out itwas never coming. I can?t fully blame them as it is also slices fault but completely unbelievable. (Edit) yet another time theychose not to deliver and canceled my order. I?ll continue to say I love their food but in terms of online orders (which theypush on you to do) they failed once again. It?s extremely frustrating and disappointing for a restaurant that does producequality food. Read more

Horrible service, ordered pizza for delivery. Told one hour...over an hour later a very rude young man called me stating they... took my card info down incorrectly. I inquired if the pizza was on the way....when he proceeded to yell at me stating "sheshould have told you it was going to be over an hour, that they were very busy!" He then asked if I wanted to cancel, not once, but three times. I finally gave him what he apparently wanted, a cancellation. Since there is a pizza place on everycorner....that's the last time that will happen. Hello Mulberry Street!! Read more

Some of the best pizza in the area and reasonably priced. Plus they have turtles in time to play for free while you wait. Really... like their version of chicken bacon ranch Read more

Visited 9/20/22 at 2:30 pm. The young lady behind the counter was very friendly and accommodating. The chicken roll was... amazing!! I will definitely be back. Read more

I love this place I have dined in and had take out for years and it never disappointed. There food has always been always fresh,... on point absolutely fulfilling with amazing creativity. Not too mention they treat there customers like family very warmenvironment. Recently had to move due to my job and my family and i still crave there food. There calzone pizza and musclesgarganzola is absolutely amazing. Read more

Cafe Europa makes an awesome Sweet Thai Chili Cicken pizza! If you're looking for something on the healthy side, the Vanessa... Skinny pizza is a good choice. How many pizza places do you know that put avocado on a cold pizza?! Read more

Best Grandma and pepperoni pizza I ever had in my life. Me , my wife and daughter have declared it our favorite and only pizza... we order . Thanks foe the love you put in making your pizza!!! Read more

Update: Still amazing! Been going here for years and I'm very picky pizza person. Favorite place for pizza! I literally drive... almost 10 minutes to get their pizza, this place is the best around. Specialty slices are amazing! Vodka is my favorite and Ialso Indulged in the Mac and cheese slice, which I can tell you anyone would eat this and it offers something different for kidsas well! Garlic knots are delicious! The staff is very friendly and place is clean. Highly recommend Read more