Reviews for Atlantis Diner in West Islip, NY
Service was slow. I ordered whole wheat pancakes and they were not very good, compared to other w/w pancakes I've eaten... elsewhere. Even my coffee refill took longer then it should have. My wife was served the wrong dish, she ordered the WesternSkillet but received a SW Skillet and had to send it back. When the right order arrived she did say it was good. Usually thefood and service is good here but this past Sunday it was subpar. Read more
Fajita Trio.... All I'm gonna say is My God that was awesome!!! I'd highly recommend this dinner we all loved our orders Our... waiter was Raul, he was awesome and really knew the menu Read more
They were understaffed and it was fine. I was visiting from SC where I now live. So good to come back home and experience a... good old fashioned Diner. My waitress was great, food was even better Read more
Clean, superb coffee, they clean the pots as soon as they are empty. Our breakfast was hot and delicious. Try the breakfast... wraps, or the french toast. You won't be sorry. Staff was very polite and friendly. Read more
My family always are here . We love the atmosphere. Unfortunately there was a waitress there that?s not there no more. We had... such a fun and pleasant experience with her . My family doesn?t want to go back because she ( Chrissy) is not there. Hopefullyshe won?t be gone for long but if anyone knows where she went please let us know. Read more
Greek yogurt parfait best I've ever had. Corned beef hash and eggs were cooked to. perfection. Well done hamburger came as... ordered. Delicious Read more
We went for breakfast. I ordered the Eggs Benedict, coffee and juice. The server was pleasant and made sure our table had all it... needed. The food was not so good. The Benedict sauce was a bit curdled and runny. It's supposed to be smooth and there wasentirely too much on the plate. Clearly, it isn't made often. A dish that isn't well made should be removed from the menu. Idon't like paying people who are just learning to cook. The 3 stars are for the server and host because they were nice andwelcoming. But, a food establishment should have quality food as well. Read more
Eating out has become more expensive but it seems diners are the places that have been hit the most. Everything was good but the... prices of kids meals seemed extra high. Read more