Reviews for Michaelangelo Pizza & Subs in West Haven, CT
The pizza is good depending on the day. The subs are really good and the bread is absolutely amazing. The counter staff are... amazing!! A few years ago I stopped ordering from here because this one girl was always so nasty!! The sauce is very good, ifI'm slow on time I'll order sauce for Sunday dinner. It is busy so I recommend calling in ahead of time. Do NOT leave your carrunning with no one in it, it's not a bad area but it's not worth it. Lastly please remember TIP the counter staff, they arepreparing your food and taking your order so please don't be cheap. Read more
Good food but the staff has terrible mouths and swear like truck drivers. Especially the bigger girl
Stuffed bread with broccoli ???? & spinach very yummy. If you are in Connecticut don?t miss this joint , parking is excellent... and restaurant is right by the road side with a Gas Station next to it. You can take a good rest and nice lunch or dinner as peryour timing?????????????????? Read more
Pizza is absolutely amazing, the flavor of the sauce will make your mouth water!! Better than average cheese and finally, the... CRUST IS KING!!! I?m sorry but I would choose this over Zuppardi?s any day! I like Zuppardi?s but Michelangelo?s MURDERS thecrust! Light, crisp and airy, NOT chewy (no thanks). Definitely try their fresh baked rolls with butter if you get to go thereearly in the day when they are hot and fresh out of the oven. A little heavy on the cheese for me personally but their sauceand crust are incredible!!! Read more
really good for a slice of pizza, selection varies. their stuffed breads all looked fabulous as well!!
Soooo upon entering, we were greeted with a big smile and cheerful energy! I visited with another trucker who stated he ate... there b4. We placed our order. I ordered egg plant fried Xtra crispy! I order it that way ALL the time. Co- worker ordered tunasub. When chef got ticket , he said no more tuna. Then he said I can get you some in 7mins. Which was a plus for me . I kno co-worker was happy bc he has been trying to get a tuna sub for days. Big Y was out the other dAy. Anywho.. when I got my sub, itlooked so hot and yummy. However, the eggplant was NOT crispy. It was slimey sliding all out sub. I went to counter, CSR said issomething the matter. I said I ordered my eggplant ???? xtra crispy and it?s not. She said well I don?t know what to tell youbecause it?s already cooked Well.. that?s what I ordered.(in my head) then I told her, I apologize I?ve never been here b4 so Ididn?t kno. She said it?s ok . Normally my eggplant is dipped in batter and fried. However, if that were not the case she couldhave simply said that is not how we make it. She asked if I wanted something else . Threw sub away with attitude NEVER madeanymore eye contact. I ordered salami, pepperoni and capicola toasted provolone and Swiss. Got sandwich 10 min later , nottoasted and no Swiss. I just knew they were gonna try and piss me off bc I returned a sub. So I did not eat it there. By thistime, my co worker was done eating . I walked out with cold sub bc I felt it and it was not toasted or hot. I said Thanx. Btw:the person who took order decided to let someone else hand it to me. Geesh I paid for what I wanted. Why have a attitude??Seemed so pleasant in beginning. I am a great cook as well as my family with EXCELLENT customer service. We are soon opening arestaurant. If customers are not pleased. I won?t get upset. Just fix the order . Is that too much to ask?? The 2 stars are forthe greeting we got and the chef who wanted to please customer by making more Tuna Read more
Just needed a slice to hold me up from a night of Margaritas. Also bought some eggplant. Both were delicious. I must return... to try more dishes, they all looked good, but unfortunately, I was strapped for time Read more
Good Sicilian pie. The staff is always friendly, and provides good service. No issues. They have a few decent desserts in the... case up front and Foxon Park soda in the cooler along with the other pizza place staples. Read more