Reviews for Frank's Trattoria (West Caldwell) in West Caldwell, NJ

Clean and pleasant staff. The regular pizza pie was delicious and the garlic knots were great tasting.

They open earlier than other pizzerias. I go there couple of times a month, comforting Saturdays lunch. I like the thick pie... they make. The dough is good and the tomato sauce doesn't taste cheap. Read more

After years of putting money into this business, today I am officially done. My order did not come and after 2 hours I have... cancelled it. After about 2.5h after placing an order, a delivery man showed up at my door banging at my door and trying to openit. All my neighbors came out. He than repetitively called my phone. Over and over and over again. He did not leave thepremises, and continued to scream at me. I called the police but he was lucky enough to leave. Please be aware. Read more

Great food but when they are busy they make mistakes with orders during delivery. I'm not one to send food back but I am sad... when orders are not correct especially when I pay more then what was delivered. Ohh well.. Read more

This has been our Pizza Friday go-to for over 20 years. It's just a solid performer with good food, service, and atmosphere.... Dominic and Philomena were the previous owners and Eddie is the current owner. The food is always consistently good. Read more

First time going to Frank?s, he was friendly and service was great, got the pizza within minutes and it tasted way better than... expected for a random stop, will defiantly stop in again when I?m the area!! Thank you! Also was a couple cents short, forgot mywallet. Frank said have a great day! Read more

Pizza by the slice seemed day old.. had a white and a sausage, just not fresh. Disappointed, I remember the pie at Frank's... being pretty good.. I'm sure if I got a whole pie and it was fresh out of the oven, it would have been good... but the slicesshould be refreshed during the day so people don't get lame slices... Read more

It took over an hour and half to get our 1 pie and garlic knots and they just threw raw green peppers all over the pizza without... even cooking it. Their delivery guy gave our order away and it took us calling with why is there this much of a delay for themto say anything. The garlic knots were stale too. Would not recommend. Read more