Reviews for Pepi's Pizza in West Allis, WI
Let?s just say I wish I would have opted for pizzeria Scotty?s ! Customer service was subpar .. pizza was cold . Crust ? What... crust? Crust was thin near nonexistent ?just an overall mediocre experience that I?ll be sure not to duplicate Read more
$14 for a large two topping! If you love paper thin crust then this is the place for you. Probably the best thin crust take out... I?ve had in Milwaukee! Read more
We are out of Towner's and always try new pizza shops. This one unfortunately was an epic fail. The cornmeal on the bottom of... the pizza was way to heavy for a thin crust. The whole circumference of pizza was burnt. Delivery was gonna take 90 minutes sowe choose to pick up, then they have us the wrong order, they immediately called after we left and gave us a free pizza forturning around. It's the only reason they got two stars and then our actual pizza wasn't even hot when we got back 2.2 miles. Thin crust and a buffalo chicken was just not good. $40 bucks for a large cheese and pepperoni and small buffalo just made itworst. Read more
My son and I decided to visit a locally owned pizza joint. After searching around a bit, I found this one. Since we were being... served before 3:00 pm, a large pizza with two toppings was $13. We chose Sausage and Pepperoni. We also ordered some very tastygarlic bread ($5.25). Toss in a couple of sodas and we thought we'd be looking at around $25. The owner was incredibly helpfuland pointed out the special of large pizza w/two toppings option. He was friendly and we felt at home with him. All of theabove is irrelevant if the food is no good. Thankfully, the food was spectacular. I thought that when we started eating it, we'dhave upwards of a 1/2 left. I was wrong. We ate it all. It was that good. Talked to the owner and the Sausage they use is theirown blend. The crust was very thin (the way I like it). It was not stiff but was flexible. The Sauce was very good aswell. After all that, the guy said: $20 for the meal. We gave him $30. It was worth it. If you like thin crust pizza, this isthe place to go. Closed on Tuesdays. Read more
First of all they have lasagna on the menu but we were told that it was being prepared and would not be available until... tomorrow. They are very short staffed and we waited well over an hour and a half for our food. The fries that came with thesandwich were so over cooked and hard they were barely eatable. The spaghetti dinner had three very small spoonsfull of saucethat tasted like it was straight out of the jar. No seasoning at all! and the amount of spaghetti received for $10.95 was ajoke. We were offered nothing.... Not even a free soda for the wait. The only reason that I gave it two stars and not one wasbecause the couple of people working were very nice. That's just not enough to make up for the disappointing food!!! Read more
This was the second time ordering a pizza. Both times not only was the Pizza awesome the staff was very kind and very family... friendly. This is now our favorite Pizza!! Cant wait to try other dishes. Read more
Appetizers pretty standard, but pizza flavor was TOP notch, absolutely delicious thin crust. Attentive staff too
Came here for a date night with my husband and was blown away by the value. Chicken nuggets, 2 beers, and a 4 topping large... pizza for only $33 - a STEAL. Plus the folks working here are kind and attentive. Definitely coming back! Read more