Reviews for New York New York Pizza in Wesley Chapel, FL

Absolute heaven of a New York style pizza, call to get it delivered so you don?t have to go through DoorDash or toast tab or... anything else. One New York style large with pepperoni and mushroom is the best thing I?ve ever tasted. Keep up the great work. Read more

always have the best experience. They always quote an hour for my deliveries but always deliver with in 20-30 minutes. Food is... ALWAYS hot and fresh. Prices are good to. No complaints over here! ???? their Philly cheese steaks are so good. Read more

I've tried a few pizza places, but this place right here ????I enjoyed, the ingredients, the taste it was so good. ???? ?? ????

This pizza is DEFINITELY a NY Style pizza. Coming from someone whom was raised and lived all over NYC from BX, Bkln, Qns,... Manhattan, S.I. and even L.I. "Fuggedaboutit" the crust is perfectly crispy and a little burnt but soft on the inside but nottoo doughy (I hate it when pizza is too doughy) the cheese is perfectly melty and stringy, and the toppings are great! Thegarlic knots also freakin FANTASTIC and the wings are pretty good too. A MUST TRY if you've Ever lived in NYC and wanna try alittle piece of home, this is the place to try. ???????????????? Only downside, they should have a couple tables inside duringthis heat...only 2 outdoor tables isn't cutting it. Read more

I Order from this place at least once a week and never had a bad experience until tonight. Ordered two large pizzas and a 2... liter of Pepsi which some how came out to over $46. Both pizzas were burnt and I don?t know what happened? But I?m not wastingmy money with this place again ???? Update - just ordered from Marco?s down the street. 2 large 2 topping pizza and a 2 litercame to $28 and that?s including tax and delivery. I miss these guys but I?m not paying these prices and still tipping thedriver for mediocre pizza like this. Read more

Excellent tasting pizza, best in town. We are from Riverview and prefer the long drive rather than any pizza in Riverview. For... some reason the pizza did taste different, it was good but different from the last couple of visits. Read more

So I grew up in New York and anyone who's lived there knows that they have arguably the best pizza. So obviously with a place... called NY NY pizza comes with some high expectations. Wow did they deliver on them...no pun intended! Stringy cheese, check!Greasy and yet filled with flavor, check! It was a taste that took me back to days of old for a moment. Not pictured here arethe boneless wings. They were so good that I ate the 10 piece before I remembered to take a photo. Try the mango habanero...itis amazing! Yep, I'm coming back! Read more

I?m from Chicago and we have great pizza. This is one of the best pizzas I have ever had!!!! I was concerned that it was going... to be rushed since I ordered the food shortly before they close on a Sunday. But it was perfect! It was absolutely delicious andlooked beautiful. I will be a repeat customer and will spread the word. I ordered the #3 Grandma pie (pizza). Thank you. Read more