Reviews for La Sicilia in Mantua Township, NJ
Ordered a large Luca from them because their is really good. It came like this and then they won?t answer the phone when I call... back. Read more
Pizza was horrible. Too much cheese, very little sauce. Phone service was horrible too. Lady on the phone was extremely rude.... Only good part was the delivery Read more
We bought a large white pizza with ricotta and broccoli rabe and it was delicious! It was cooked perfectly.
Good pizza, awesome meatball sandwich but the absolute best reason to go, aside from the friendly staff, is the Paula's Salad.... I'm not usually a salad eater, but wow. Read more
The cheese on this pizza is hands down the best pizza cheese on a Jersey pizza ...It's not clumpy or sloppy...Melts... perfectly..... Probably made on the premises...Blows away shore pizza and all pizzas in the surrounding areas of South Jersey Read more
Being a Jersey boy, I?m pretty particular about my pie, and this right here, is some damn good pizza. Perfect, easy fold,... slight flop, oil-run-down-your-elbow slice with a crisp but chewy crust and the right amount of cheese and savory pepperoni. IfI were David Portnoy I?d give this at least a 7.5 if not a solid 8. Maybe even a 9. Great pie. Get some. Read more
Refuses to pick up the phone after 8pm any day of the week despite being ?open? until 9-9:30. In person the shop is closed... too. Rarely able to make an order :( Read more
The best pizza in town and staff is so kind and patient. I once had issues with my card and the cashier was so understanding... while I called my bank.. Also the salads with shrimp are AMAZING!! Read more