Reviews for Mark's Pizzeria in Webster, NY
Used to be my family's go-to pizza spot. While they still, in my opinion, make the best calzones their prices have slowly... crawled up. I almost always do pick up wherever I order from and the staff has always been nice. The quality of the food doesvary from time to time but has never been bad. With limited parking up front I now almost always just park in the back. I bumpedit down to four stars for three reasons. First being the slow price hike. The second and third is likely a building owner thingbut I feel like I may fall through the wooden ramp to the back entrance and the other is that the other tenant makes Mark'ssmell very strongly like pot. However I don't think it makes any impact on the quality of the food. Regardless, this is stillone of the best Mark's which does have great food. Read more
Very good pizza and wings. Fast and friendly service. Highly recommend.
Excellent pizza, easy to use app, always hot and ready by the time I get there. Custom pizza pies are the bomb. Better than... Salvatore's... Read more
Love the pizza here and the service is one of the best! I highly recommend ordering your pies from here. They're that good and... the have other amazing food items too that everybody will love. Read more
We ordered 4 sheet pizzas for our Webster Schroeder Field Hockey team from Mark's and they gave us a great price and had... everything ready on time. The pizzas were delicious! Read more
I order alot of food from marks pizza between me and my wife. Just this week we have dropped 75 bux there 2 times in a row now... I have gotten blue cheese for my calzone I hate blue cheese asked for ranch ordered online both times. I chose ranch somethingapparently happen because both times I didnt get what I asked for. I have no problens going to salvatores or pizza hut or anyother establishment in webster to spend my money. I get told when I called nothing they can do really?? over sides your willingto lose a customer. I will never order from marks again just on the principle of being told there is nothing they can do. Ididnt even want free food just bring me my dipping sauces like you did last time this happen 2 days ago. They dont want mybuisness over bringing me 2 damn dipping sauces. If you use the on line order check and recheck your order. Read more
Whoever manages this place (Bay Rd.) deserves a raise. My wife and I always struggle with food delivery in Webster-it?s always... a gamble-order the same dish from the same place 5 times, and it seems to never be the same. Not this place. The consistencytruly is remarkable. When we order, we know exactly what to expect, and are never disappointed. We always order online andcustomize every aspect of everything we order (they probably hate us). Yet and still, It?s always the same, every time. Forwhatever reason, we just can?t seem to find that anywhere else in Webster. Also, they have the best delivery people. Everysingle one gets it here hot, snow or shine-and is so nice. So much better than the random GrubHub or DoorDash drivers. Gottagive credit where it?s due-this place is killing it. Read more
The pizza is pretty amazing and the service is always top notch. They have a great menu selection and the prices are reasonable... too. Read more