Reviews for Antietam Dairy in Waynesboro, PA
We must have came on a bad day. We waited 30 minutes for our ice cream yet we were the only ones there when we ordered. They... took the orders of the family after us before they worked on our order. They were out of half the things they said they had. Ourorder was changed multiple times because of that. On top of all that, my wife found plastic in her food. This place seems tohave gone down hill. No one knew what was going on. Read more
I have been looking for lemon ice cream for years and finally found this place!!! Many other great flavors also!!! Delicious!!!... Staff friendly!!! Read more
Very good ice cream! And looks to be a popular place with the locals, but I didn?t care for the cash only policy. ???????
Best ice cream I've ever had. Cash only, no frills, but it's the best ice cream you will buy. Tons of flavors and I've never had... a bad one. Go to Antietam Dairy! Read more
Best ice cream in town. I loved it my family loved and even my dogs loved it. Run by a nice local family wish we had more places... like this high recommend. Read more
Nice local ice cream shop. They offer a ton of flavors. It can be a bit slow if they are busy, but worth the wait. The... only thing to keep in mind is that they are Cash Only, so come prepared. I recommend trying Moose Tracks if you like chocolateand peanut butter Read more
Amazing sugar free premium ice cream! Keto, diabetics and other no-sugar consumers should be FLOCKING to this place! Its so... difficult to FIND though :( Allll the ice cream takes u to Heaven on Earth, but the sugar-free AMAZED me w zero aftertaste andits homemade! Ran by a sweet staff & dashing cashier & has an awesome, alternating flavor selection. ;) I live almost 2 hrsaway so i get the pre-made half gallons and up! :) Read more
A favorite for decades. Great dairy ice cream. Lots of flavors. A bit pricey tho.