Reviews for Donny's Girl II Supper Club in Watertown, WI
Must have been an off night for them tonight. We were there at 4:30 pm with reservations for 5:00 pm. After sitting at the bar... we watched many others being seated before us. Checked and found out they lost our reservations. While waiting in the bar areasaw a man use his finger to wipe the cheese off the knife back into the cheese spread container. Turned me off of the relishbar. Once seated had a very nice waitress. Salad bar was very good except for the large plastic wrapper my Sister pulled out ofher salad. Food was good. The relish bar should be moved next to the salad bar in the restaurant area. Out of place andinconvenient in the bar Read more
Had 3 take out fish. I live 5 minutes away, was there promptly. Had dine in fish last week and was very good. This take out was... the worst fish fry I have ever had. Fish was over cooked and tough. Fries were ice cold. There were only 2 slaw and potatoessalad cups. The clam chowder has a funny after taste, and not good. No bread. I supported this restaurant through the pandemic.Very dispointed Read more
Their cook is very unprofessional. I ordered a shrimp cocktail and didn?t finish it. The waiter asked how it was and I said not... so great given that it made me sick note I am not allergic to shrimp and this was the first time. I wasn?t mad at all thingshappen. The waiter was very kind and said it looked a little weird and took it back. The cook apparently ate the shrimp off myplate and said ?this tastes fine to me maybe a little under cooked.? I shouldn?t hear that from the dining room. Then a coupleof minutes later he said ?I hope she doesn?t want any chicken or shrimp on her Alfredo and is going to take two and a halfhours.? and they weren?t busy. That?s when I got up and left. I told the bartender what just happened and she didn?t even looksurprised and went back to the kitchen. When the cook talks down about a guest who isn?t mad and has no intention of cooking asimple meal correctly that doesn?t make me want to stay and taste the food they prepared. Read more
Wanted some Prime Rib and heard it was good. Made reservations for 2 at 6:30. Didn?t get in until 7:15 as we were going to... leave. Ordered the Prime Rib (medium and medium well) came to us rare and raw. Had to send it back 3 times. Not asking for muchbut didn?t even get a free dessert. A very bad night for us Read more
Have not been there since the new ownership took over earlier this year. Stopped by to get 2 fish dinners to go and an appetizer... which was cheese curds. ordered the fish dinners with soup. When I got home and inspected the food, I noticed the soup was notthere. We were supposed to get five pieces of fish each, one dinner only had four. The fish pieces were small and somewhatovercooked. The French fries were undercooked and soggy. The sides that came with the dinner were a joke, you got coleslaw andpotato salad. They only gave literally 1 tablespoon of each, we measured it. The cheese curds you only received about 9 and theywere very greasy, not worth what I paid for them. I will say the staff was friendly. We have been going to this place for a longtime and the food was always good. Definitely a drastic decline in food quality, not what I expected from this place I thoughtso highly of. I have never left a review before, but I felt I had to this time. It's not to try and hurt the business but tohelp it. I hope management takes this constructive criticism to improve the quality of the food to the standards that Donny'sGirl has been known for and what I have been enjoying since I moved to Watertown in 2005. Read more
Staff was friendly. Seated fairly soon after arriving. Salad bar was a little limited. Several items were empty, they did refill... after trip. My steak was not very well seasoned. Read more
A short wait at the bar sipping on an excellent, brandy, old-fashioned sweet. We ordered at the table executed perfectly by our... wonderful waitress, Judie! Way too much food, but all in all worth the 40-minute drive! P.S. I highly recommend the margaritawine ???? Read more
Under new management it has drastically improved. Prices have gone up but it's worth it. Faster seating, faster food delivery,... the wait staff is great. Always nice and friendly, and busting their butts to get work done. Tip them well, they deserve it. Read more