Reviews for The Pizza Shop in Warrensburg, NY
Great family business with a great origin story. Only thing greater is the taste of the pizza. Best around, always worth the... trip. Read more
First visit..I live two towns away. Ordered stromboli with pepperoni, sausage and ricotta added. It was excellent! Plce is nice... and clean and staff are friendly. Prices are reasonable! Try them out, you won't be sorry. Read more
Very friendly and the pizza and one of the best I had in the area just to me it could use a little more sauce. I will... definitely order from there again. Read more
I had a nice turkey club wrap, the ingredients tasted fresh and the wrap was full of flavor.
We stopped here on the way home from six flags. We were hungry for some good, quick pizza (with three exhausted kids) and that?s... just what we found. The staff were nice and friendly and the pizza came out much quicker than expected and it was delicious!Also reasonably priced. We will definitely eat here again. Read more
Wow wow wow. My Margherita pizza was amazing. I haven't had pizza that good since I was in Italy. The sauce was so fresh. ... Garlic knots were delicious too. I am so glad I found this place. We will be back! Read more
Great pizza. Fast counter service. Available by the slice (quickly warmed and served at tables). Fewer pre-made pizza choices... after 7 pm. Large menu of whole pizza toppings and non-pizza choices. Friendly staff. Fun murals on the walls. Regularly andhigh top tables. Take out available. Wished they had waited to sweep up until after we finished eating and left. Read more
Very good pizza. New york thin crust. Bone in chicken wings were crispy and flavorful. And we actually received the extra blue... cheese we requested. We order 3 pizzas and a Ceasar salad, meatball platter, 2 kinds of bone in wings. Only thing for us.Chicken Ceasar salad was a little dry with the Ceasar dressing. Perfect foldable slices! Read more