Reviews for Geppetto's Pizza in Wanaque, NJ
Gepetto's is located on Ringwood Avenue in Wanaque NJ. It's most adorable, rustic cozy atmosphere gives off the vibe of family... and positivity. I ordered the vegetable pizza and it was huge and perfectly Delicious.... Read more
Edit new review: Ordered from them today and was looking forward to it and pizza with a bug on the pizza we had to take off, I?m... so mad but they?re closed now so this is the last time. Picture is below. I?m not going to complain about it but oh well? Idon?t know how I haven?t tried Geppettos sooner. My normal spot was closed today so I decided to give them a try. I liveliterally 6 or 7 houses away from the location. I went online and found a family combo of 2 large pies an order of garlic knotsand a 2 liter soda. It was like 35$ and to be honest the pizza was magnificent. The only real reason I haven?t tried themsooner, and I?ll admit I feel kind ve foolish now, is because people always say they aren?t that great. I disagree respectfully.They are REALLY good. The pizza is great the price is great and the garlic knots while not the best I?ve had were still decent.I will certainly be coming to them weekly for the same family combo on pizza night. They won me over on the first try. If itstays consistent then I won?t ever switch from them but I?ll be back after the 3rd buy to let you know if it was consistent ornot. Thanks Geppettos. Read more
Unfortunately they missed the mark here completely. I ordered a couple of pies, grilled chicken sandwich, and a side order of... meatballs. This was by far... by miles... and miles the worse grilled chicken sandwich I've had in my entire life. Not surewhere to begin.. they couldn't be bothered to put some lettuce or tomotoes on it. The chicken basically tasted like it wasboiled? Defrosted? Who knows.... the "fresh mozarella" was basically shredded cheese that was lumped up in this ball oftasteless chicken and passed off as a "grilled chicken sandwich. Disgusting... I could not even eat a few bites of it. Look atthe picture for yourself and you be the judge. My kids said the pizza was good so no complaints there honestly. The meatballstasted like it had more bread than meat in it or whatever ingredients they use to bunch it together. I normally order from heremaybe once a month and it is either hit or miss.... more misses with their secondary items. If your going to order ONLY pizzathis spot is okay at best. If your going to order other items you have many better nearby options. I'm severely dissapointed andprobably won't be going back. Read more
The lady who works here is very nice and is always friendly to me when I come in for pizza. The pizza is pretty heavy on the... cheese which some people might not like, but it?s a nice change of pace every now and again. The other offerings are solid butto be honest I have only had a few things other than pizza from there. The decor is also very unique for a pizza place! Read more
Very, very good pizza. Way better than your average Italian pizzeria. I just came to the neighborhood and this is the best one... of the few I tried so far. I ordered an artichoke, roasted red pepper and black olives pizza and it was cooked perfectly. Doughwas golden cripsy on the edges (most pizzerias are either undercooked or burnt) and ingredients were on point. Not greasy andoily and not too dry. Buffalo Wings were crispy and delicious. there's attention to detail in the food they make. Will orderagain. Read more
I found this place when I moved to Ringwood and I'm glad. You can tell they've been making the pizza the way they do for a long... time. It's like a classic pizza that grandma makes. I really enjoy it. The lady behind the counter is really nice too. I givethe place a thumbs up. Read more
Very good service and the pizza looked delicious. Unlike other pizzerias their crust on the bottom is on the thicker side and... more chewy than I expected. It was good pizza don't get me wrong, but it felt like I was biting into a hybrid Sicilian/plainslice. There is also not much parking there so when you go there hopefully they're not crowded otherwise you'll be parkingacross the street in another lot. Read more
Good food at a decent price. A real home town gem. The owner is sweet and makes you feel like you're a guest in her home.