Reviews for Natale's Pizzeria & Catering in Waldwick, NJ
Great service and prices like they should be, solid pizza spot
My family has gotten food from Natale's for many years. Natale's used to be good, but has slowly gone down hill for a while... now. Now they are horrible. Yesterday my mother and I each got an order of the Juicy Lucy and an order of baked zeti. We boththought the Juicy Lucy was very dry and the roast beef was dried out. Shortly after eating the sandwhich I started feeling ill,but it passed. I saved the baked zeti for after work. When I ate it it tasted a bit off, but not too bad. Later that night Ifelt sick again and had many trips to the bathroom. My mother that felt really sick after eating a little bit of the baked zetiand got sharp pains in her stomach all night. Almost had to go to the hospital. Today I took a look at her left over zeti andsaw many of the peices of zeti were a dark brown color, almost black. This was not just the top layer peices under the chesethat could be explained as maybe just burnt. The black peices were all over in the container. It seems Natale's is usingexpired and/or rotton pasta. My family is never going to get good from them again. Read more
First of all, it's pronounced ?Nat Al?s.? Once you get beyond the phonetics, you're talking about the best neighborhood pizzeria... in Bergen County. Natale?s is not a coal oven, epicurean, trying too hard pizza experience. Rather, Natale?s provides dyed inthe wool North Jersey pizza perfection. The crust is thin and crispy. The sauce is tangy with a hint of sweetness, and it'snever applied too thickly. The cheese is gooey for the perfect, salty, stringy pull without ever being chewy or rubbery. Thepizza is, in a word, perfect. Natale?s also makes amazing sandwiches on their soft, fresh bread. Wonderful salads on expertlyselected greens that are never brown or soggy. And pasta that are never starchy or overcooked and mushy. In short, Natale?s isNorth Jersey, Bergen County pizza perfection. It's worth the drive. It's worth the wait. It's simply the best Read more
Ordered two pizzas to go, service was very friendly fast and convenient would definitely recommend this place being from out of... town this place was suggested and it was a good suggestion Read more
My Ex's family always ordered their pizza orders from Natale's Pizza. Their pizza was always the best. The name that they used... to order was "Mastro". The Mastromonico's lived in Ho-Ho-Kus. Because Mastromonico was too long to spell over the phone. Therotation ovens made the baking process fantastic, this was 1983. I have had your pizza @ My Daughter's house in Waldwick,NJ. Read more
Ridiculously good pizza. Old school pizza spot. Keep this place ALIVE! Recommend the Buffalo chicken pizza, fresh and delicious.... Also this place has the coolest oven I?ve seen. I?ve been eating pizza for 27 plus years and I?ve never seen this oven! Read more
Go see Pedro at Natales and he will deliver a very good slice of Pizza. The Sauce is the first thing that hits you with this... Pizza. The ratio of sauce to cheese is very good. The crust was good, maybe could have been cooked a pinch longer, but it hadvery good taste. I really liked the stools inside for a quick slice and go. Was an above average slice, we shall see where theyrank on the Pizza Hunters App. Thanks Pedro. Read more
For over 42 years, Natale's Pizza is still excellent, and consistent! Still my fav since junior year in high school!