Reviews for James Angelo's Underground Pizza in Waimea, HI

The thin crust pizza is tasty. owner is super friendly and recommended great local ingredients.

If you pass Ohana Fuel station you missed the place. Worth the drive if you are in downtown kailua. Pizza with crunchy thin... crust is delicious. Try the lasagna, spaghetti and meatballs. They come with garlic bread. Read more

If you are looking for a damn good NY style Pizza look no further than James Angelo?s Underground Pizza. Kind, quick and... friendly. Compared to what you would pay for Mediocre food this AMAZING pizza was a STEAL. The crust is perfection, no utensilsrequired. Perfectly thin and crispy on the bottom & nice and chewy with the dough bubbles around the sides. The sauce is freshand zesty just like a tomato from the garden. I?m very picky about cheese and the cheese really good. The toppingsize/distribution was like a work of art. FYI: BYOB & Cash only but there is a store right next door for supplies and cash. Read more

This is the best Pizza in town. The crust is perfect. Toppings, on point. Very very tasty. Order comes very quickly. Service is... top notch. If you don't know go find out. Read more

This place has sooooo much character!! They are rocking out 50?s dance tunes at a volume you?d want. It sets the tone for the... vibe of what feels like an actual 50?s pizza place. The owner(?) feels like a guy from New York (East coast accent)?and has theoriginal grit it would take to make an authentic New York Pizza that they are clearly pulling off. Local one-of-kind placeslike this make little Waimea town so special. I?m a local from the other side of the island?and I?ll be back every time Icruise through this area. Read more

Went here looking to get a good pizza got disappointed instead. Crust was burned on half of pizza. Crust was dry like a saltine... cracker. Cheese was pretty much non existent. The ham and pineapple were just scarce. Basic crust and sauce type pizza. The boxwas heavier than the pizza. I know a business has one chance to get it right the first time. This was not a puzza that shouldhave been served. Read more

Great pizza - gluten free pizza crust & vegetarian options. Made to order food tailored to individual preferences.

One of the things I miss about my childhood homestate, New York, is the NY style pizza. You just can't find it anywhere... else. Discovering James Angelo's Underground Pizza however was a pleasant surprise for me as they make NY style pizza just asgood, if not better, than the pizza I remember eating back at home. Not only do they have NY style pizza they also have NYstyled calzones! The ingredients are really fresh and they have a really nice selection of toppings you don't see back on themainland. They even have the option of you bringing your own toppings if they don't have it on their menu! Whether you'restopping by for a quick slice or a whole pie, I would recommend giving this place a try. One thing to note: CASH ONLY! Read more