Reviews for Goodfellas Pizzeria in Vinita, OK
Visiting from Texas. Pizza was ok. Should I ever return I'll ask for no bell peppers and add extra sauce. It was dry to me.... Expensive for a small pizza. They're making a killing off these small town people Read more
A nice little pizza joint. Older Building with character... Lots of OU and Oklahoma memorabilia. Starters... Chef Salad, see the... picture. Maybe a cup of Iceberg lettuce with a few diced tomatoes and onions, a handful of croutons. And a minimal amount of hamand less than strip of bacon. Someone made a lot of money on this. Pizza.. The Boss basically a supreme pizza. We got thelarge. The original crust was good, nothing fancy. The sauce was a little to sweet to me, but good overall. Generous amounts oftoppings which all seemed good quality. Cheese bread... Basically a pizza crust with a buncha cheese melted on it. Not badoverall, but a little over cooked on the crust. Canned/bottled soda. Very nice staff. The place was charming overall. Aboveaverage pizza. Read more
The cheeseburger pizza ???? is absolutely delicious. Loaded with tons of cheese and toppings. The boss is just as good and ham... sandwich is wonderful. Read more
Pretty expensive for what you get. toppings aren?t distributed evenly. calzones are half empty. used to be a really good place.... Kind of disappointing Read more
Surprised in Vinita. Goodfellas has a throwback style pizza and crust, lots of cheese and the sauce was bright. Plenty of... toppings, and they were fresh and flavorful. Atmosphere was a mishmash of old school memorabilia and classic cars and art.Bathroom was very clean. Read more
This awesome pizza. Best had in a long time. Wonderful surprise after traveling all day. Will stop here on my way through again
Texans stopping by and I have to say: BEAUTIFUL. Very humble and welcoming place. Was craving wings, but thought we?d try out... the local specialty; Pizza. No regrets. In fact, I am grateful for doing so. Yeah it?s about $10+ but honestly even the smallpizza fills up a couple of people really well. The pizza looked really presentable and was too good not to leave my feedback.Really great place and food. Wish them the best with the coming time. Read more
We picked up a pizza on 11/26 and ate about 1/3 of it before we found two hairs baked into the crust. So gross. We were already... in the turnpike before we realized it or we could have brought it back. So disappointing. Read more