Reviews for Pudgie's Pizza in Vestal, NY
Meatball subs are delicious. Pizza is subpar. Desserts are ok.
Pudgies Pizza is the best pizza joint in the vestal area. Outstanding food and customer service every time I go inside their... store. Read more
Called Pudgies to report an issue with an online pick up order that was missing ingredients on a sub. Did not notice this until... I arrived home. Immediately, without asking, the team member offered to remake the sub and have it delivered at no charge. Customer satisfaction is 10 stars if it would have been allowed. Thank you for a prompt resolution and making it right! Read more
My son and I stopped by there late at night and ordered their Stromboli. We love Pudgies and this particular one, by far made... the best one ever. Keep in mind that growing up in Horseheads, I frequented Pudgies because they are superior to many pizzashops out there. I hope that I find myself in Vestal again so I can try other items on their menu. Keep up the great work andthank you. Read more
So I ordered a large cheese pizza when it got here it was mashed up a big disgrace so I called the store and they made me... another one and it was in the same shape once it arrived the manager said she thinks the driver is speeding well of she thinkshe's speeding then he should be fired this is NOT good quality its terrible this was my first time ordering pizza from here andits my last Read more
Love Pudgie's so much. Pizza is great, wings are great, steak and cheese is great, fried cauliflower is great. Have literally... never had a bad experience. Bought a growler too because why not? Aesthetics of the building are really super cool too.Pineapple bacon pizza is my absolute favorite from them. Read more
Pudgie's is one of my family's go to pizza places! We always get a chicken bacon ranch pizza with wing sauce added and every... time it's AMAZING. And I'm BIG into EXTRA crispy wings and they truly deliver!!! The absolute best wings around!! Read more
I stopped for a dinner to take home. Italian sub was great, actually had it for breakfast. French fries were so undercooked I... fed them to my chickens. Boneless wings were over cooked and hard, shared them to the dogs and chickens. I spent 34.00 Dollarsand the sub was great. The sub rolls at pudgies are excellent. The rest of the food was a disappointment. Read more