Reviews for Sicilia Italian Pizzeria in Venice, FL
Best pizza within 50 miles without a doubt. Real Sicilians from Italy really know how to make pizza. Who knew! Try it, you'll... like it. Oh they do need to expand their hours. Hopefully once they are here for a while longer. Read more
1 star doesn?t even do justice to how horrid our food was tonight. We ordered garlic knots with extra cheese, a gluten free... pizza, and Buffalo wings. Holy moly was the food awful. The garlic knots were cold, burnt, and stuck to the tinfoil. We paidfor extra cheese and it?s literally a tub of stuck on cheese and grease. The food was cold, the delivery said 45 minutes and itactually took 90+ minutes. It arrived in a wet paper bag of grease that was falling apart. The Buffalo wings were awful, cold,and tiny. We paid 12 dollars for 8 of the smallest wings you?ll ever see. I will say that once the gluten free pizza wasreheated under the broiler it was good. My son has celiac so his delivery options are limited. We?re glad his food wassalvageable. I have no idea how this place has such high reviews. I will never consider this place again. EDIT: I just readthe reply from the business and it is full of inaccuracies. I did not call the store repeatedly as was stated - I didn't evencall once - nor did you deliver the meal personally. It was delivered via HungerRush where we gave the driver a $10 cash tip -this was not the driver's fault by any stretch. HungerRush doesn't specify a tip amount pre-order, so we tipped cash. Soswing and a miss for remembering this order from the first week of March. The food was poorly prepared, cold (not lukewarm),burned, stuck to the pain, and overwhelmingly greasy. Blaming the customer with a reply full of inaccuracies is ridiculous. Weordered from you because we have a child with Celiac, so we do not have your implied "new relationship" with Little Caesar'spizza. Using Little Caesar's as an insult is low brow at best - they have nothing to do with this review. Read more
Came off the beach looking for some fresh local pizza and we hit a gem! Fresh hand tossed sour dough crust! Garlic knots were... great! The arugula salad was excellent! Highly recommended! Dining was also a lot of fun with the great staff! If you are inthe area swing in and order up some food! Read more
I've been to A LOT of local pizza shops, searching for the best, and I think I've found my absolute favorite. The sourdough... crust in particular is hands down the best in Venice. Really sets it apart from the competition. While obviously not as good asreal cheese, the vegan cheese alternative is actually pretty decent and appreciated if you're looking for it. The only thingthat would make this place better is if I lived closer and they offered a BLT pizza. (Suggestion: Crispy bacon peices, dicedtomato, herbed mayo sauce, and shredded romaine lettuce with a light drizzle of Italian dressing on the side when ready to top.All on that wonderful sourdough crust... That would be perfection!) Read more
Amazing pizza and wings! Center of pizza was just a little bit soggy, could have used another min or two but the flavor was... excellent and the toppings were fresh. Staff was very friendly and made sure to verify everything was correct before payment. Read more
Really delicious pizza! We got the veggie pizza, and a Build your own with pepperoni, mushrooms, and olives. The crust was still... crisp and flavorful by the time we got it home. Both pizzas were good, but we both really enjoyed the veggie pizza. The onlyissue was the online ordering for BYO wasn?t super clear on pricing, so I had no idea what my total would be until I checkedout. Read more
Amazing! The crust, sauce, meats, including the cup pepperoni, and the peppers were absolutely delicious and cooked to... perfection. Upon arrival to pick up my order, I was greeted by multiple employees, all with smiles. The pizza was ready and theemployee lifted the lid to let me preview the pizza, a gesture that I appreciated, as it shows they have pride in theirwork! Gulf Coast Pizza is now our go to destination for Pizza night. We will definitely share our opinions with friends. Thankyou! Read more
I loved this place! The pizza was very authentic, the flavors are very unique. The olive oil made it pop out. The crust was... amazing as well. The owner was very nice, welcoming, funny, and likeable. The wait time was long when we first came there as itwas Friday night, so that was understandable. There were many accommodations like a high chair for babies. Pizzas were a bitexpensive, but they were very delicious. There was also a wide variety of drinks like Sicilia Wine, soda, and water. We wentagain, would recommend! Read more