Reviews for The Original Goodie Shop in Upper Arlington, OH

Not bad, not great would sum up my experience. My expectations were high since the line was 10 people deep out the door on a... Saturday morning shortly after opening. I was excited to try the apple fritter, which had zero apples in it and was definitelyundercooked. I also tried a strawberry cream crescent which was very bland and lacked flavor (while also being very light onfilling. The glazed donut was also disappointing- undercooked/very doughy with the glaze lacking in flavor. They can dobetter! Read more

My usual cookie lady was out on maternity leave so I decided to give this place a shot. Purchased cookies for my business and... they were terrible. They were supposed to say the name of my business in black with white icing on the cookie. Not difficult -instead the business name was green and when I took one out of the bags to look at it, the logo smeared everywhere and toreapart. We paid extra for bags and then were told after we called that we were supposed to wait 24 hours to bag them althoughthey offered to bag them before my husband left the shop but he decided to bag them at home since he was in a hurry. Partiallymy fault because I let my husband pick them up, I would have never left with cookies that looked like that. My event was thenext morning, when I got home that evening I called and they offered to refund me 15%..the cookies were not usable and I had tothrow them out and throw something else together last minute. Honestly I can?t believe they were willing to let those leavetheir place of business or be handed out with their name tied to them. I am editing my review to reflect the reply left by thebusiness: it may have been 20%, sure 15 or 20 either way I never received it. You offered for me to drive them back up there soyou could scrape the logo off and put a new one back on and told me it would take about 3 hours and also said you wouldn?t beable to bag them. There wasn?t enough time before my event for this to happen, nor did I have 5 hours (including travel time) toaccomplish this. At minimum someone could have remade them and I could have drove up there and picked them up saving me the 3hours production time. Nonetheless, I needed individually wrapped take home cookies, which is what I paid for. I have never lefta negative review for another business, but these should have been refunded. Actually they should have never been sold to mebecause they were green and my order was for black. Read more

AWAYS AMAZING! Look at this fabulous cake for Frankie, our English Springer Spaniel! Almost too beautiful to cut, but TOO... delicious NOT to. Thank you for your talents! Mark & Gary Read more

We used the Goodie shop for our wedding on 9/16/22. We have been working with Emilie since last year for tastings and getting... the perfect cake for our wedding day. Emilie was amazing. She was very responsive and helpful throughout the entire process!She even helped with delivery last minute when we ran into some problems with pick up. The cake itself was incredible withperfect flavor. We went simple with white wedding cake with almond frosting and all of our guests were talking about how amazingit was! We will be using the goodie shop for future dessert needs and recommend them to everyone! Read more

Amazing!! You have to try their Tea cookies and their iced cookies!! Great cupcakes as well (the chocolate icing isn?t very... sweet though ). They also have amazing prices, we got so much for about 15 dollars and some change. Read more

A true Columbus / UA staple . I love this bakery . I?ve been going my whole life . I love their cookies best . Great... buttercream. Cakes have a unique texture . Not for everyone . Doughnuts are popular but I think they?re just okay . Big ontheir cookies Great staff . Read more

I ordered donuts for pick up this weekend and when I got there they were about the size the normal are. The lady was nice gave... me a discount which was okay. Then I got home and ate one and there was no cream at all in the long John. I?m not sure if therewas a new baker or what happened but hopefully this is a one time event. Regardless it was for my dad for Father?s Day and itwas very disappointing! Read more

The Original Goodie Shop did both of my Mother's 70th birthday cakes, and they were absolutely beautiful, and tasted delicious!... Thank you. Read more