Reviews for Lucy's New York Style Pizza in Twin Falls, ID
It was burnt on the bottom but the middle was under-cooked. The sauce wasn?t spread evenly so some parts didn?t have any and... even the cheese wasn?t melted in spots. It reminded me more of an Italian style pie with the thick burnt edges than a NY style. Read more
I ordered a half supreme/half pacific pizza and got a half supreme/half cheese pizza. The pizza itself was just plain bad.... There was so much cheese on it that you couldn't even begin to hold the slice in your hand. The actual crust was thin and had nostructure to support the unreasonable amount of cheese. Will not be ordering from here again. Read more
Ordered a supreme through GrubHub and got a cheese pizza with basil on it. A bit disappointed because I paid the price for the... supreme. Cannolis we're good. Pizza was good but I probably won't order from here again. Just giving people a heads up is all. Read more
Great pizza and friendly service. The 12? filled me up. Could?ve fed two. Cost about $13.
Awesome pizza! Ordered take-and-bake with cheese (of course), extra red sauce, and pepperoni, bell peppers and mushrooms. It was... ready in 12 minutes, and the cook was kind enough to hand it to me personally while describing how to bake it. So fresh-tasting,no grease, and no excess of salt! Very reasonable price too. A very pleasant flavor and quality surprise in Idaho. Wish Ilived nearby! Read more
Outstanding service, pizza & meatball subs. Cool atmosphere too. Very, very close to NY style. Chewy crust, tangy sauce, stringy... cheese. Meatballs are on point. Our go-to in Twin Falls. Read more
This new pizza joint was amazing. Checked out the new 2nd street Market and decided to try this pizza. So good! Might be the... best pizza in Twin Falls. My girlfriend and I loved every bit of the pie and the breadsticks. Read more
Great pizza! Hot, cheesy and the crust was perfect. ????