Reviews for Olde Towne Tavern in Tuscarawas, OH
Me and my bf went here to eat for the first time. I had an Italian sub and salad, both were really good! The bathrooms were... clean! And the prices are decent! Only downside was the waiting time for everything was a bit long since there was only 1waitress on our side. And My bf had gotten the Mac and cheese bowl and it was watery and bland. Other than that, we would eathere again! Read more
Excellent food!! Love the remodeling, Wednesday pasta specials and new patio seating. Pretzels, wings and steak are... fantastic!! Great live guitar music from JP and others. Very clean and tidy throughout. When busy you can experience longerwait times from the brick oven but it's well worth it. Family friendly dining room area. Read more
We come to Tusky about every 3 weeks from Columbus to take care of my mother in laws house! We have past by the Olde Town... Tavern probably hundreds of times and I tell my husband we need to try it! Tonight we did, it was great, I wish had tried itsooner! Very good food, we will go back! ???? Read more
Service was great. Clean environment. Food was very good and with great prices . I loved the style of the bar and just overall... had a great experience. We will definitely be going back! Read more
One of the best filet mignon I?ve ever had, tender!. Looks as if one of the secrets in preparation is the cooking process takes... place in a wood fired pizza oven. Read more
Fantastic gem in Tusky. Great atmosphere, plenty of room, and fantastic food. You wouldn't expect a place like this to cook a... great steak, but there wasn't an item I had that wasn't good. This is now one of my favorites. It fills up quick, so get thereearly and don't expect super quick service. Our waitress always kept drinks full at our table, but I think the kitchen was alittle slower than other places. That's probably due to how many people were there though. Read more
I went into this restaurant recently knowing that it was recently purchased and renovated to be an Italian type restaurant and... bar. I came after a very hard day of work and was exhausted and hungry. Unfortunately, I came during a busy moment and right atthe time the kitchen closed. The place was packed and only one table left. The gentleman who seated me was extremely hospitableand attentive. I believe it is owned and ran by him and his son. I ordered the filet mignon with assorted veggies and a sidesalad. I love filet mignon and have had it at some of the finest restaurants during my time living in Atlanta. I knew if theirfilet was good, then everything else would be. I will simply say, I was far from being disappointed. That was the best filetmignon of my entire life! The salad and the veggies were scrumptious as well but that steak was soo good I thought about it allweek after leaving! I went back the following week with a friend and we both got filet mignon and it was just as good the secondtime, as well! The only criticism I have is that it needs to learn to make fresh brewed good quality sweet tea. Maybe that'sjust the south still pumping through my veins, but you can't have five star steak and two star sweet tea. I would highlyrecommend this place to anybody who enjoys good quality food! One of my biggest frustrations with moving from a major city to asmall town is the lack of quality restaurants. This place is a hidden treasure and worth the trip to Tusky! It's a breath offresh air in an area full of mediocre mom and pop restaurants. I'll be going back regularly and inviting everyone I know. Read more
One word to sum up our whole experience: bland. The food was bland, the decor inside was bland, the service was bland. There was... no personality to this place at all. No decor barely. We ordered an appetizer, pizza, and pasta and it all was greasy and lackluster in flavor. We had high expectations as everyone says they love the food here. Our server was very new (said she?s beenthere a month) and unfamiliar with the menu and was just very spacey and often forgot things we asked for repeatedly. The onlypositive I can think of was the $5 strawberry margarita special cocktail. Read more