Reviews for Mystic Islands Casino in Little Egg Harbor Township, NJ

Went there last night (11/4/2022), had a sweet server named Brittany, had the burger ruben and it was fantastic, could only eat... half so I had the other today for lunch. If I have one minor complaint, the Fat Tire beer was a little flat. But this is a greatstop, with a very broad menu. Read more

If zero stars was an option I would good is actually like 3-4 stars with price and results in mind I have this one bartender... that I guess has a problem with me idk anyway ordered a beer was asked if I wanted a menu and because I thought if I wanted itnow or later was told he was uncomfortable serving me but yet I have seen many instances of over serving here idk why I wasmaking them uncomfortable when I live 5 mins walking distance away makes no sense?.. black hair 5?5? makes nothing but problemsI?m sure he?s great with others but he?s bias with me cause I hit on ppl he knows his friend told me so don?t mix friends andwork Read more

Family went early2022 had a great time. Nice waiter,good food,nice people. Didn't like the NBA, NFL, sports etc that were all... over the TV's. Tired of the WOKE sports. Want OAN & Newsmax. Since my 5 star review, we went back(aug2022) & I've reduced thereview to 4 stars. My son & I ordered the wings and they were very poor quality & many portions of the wings were unedible &mine sat in a pool of sauce. I also ordered penne vodka with chicken and the flavor was not exciting at all. There was livemusic that night which was nice. Seafood bisque soup was good. Avoid the wings! Read more

Had several people recommend the cheesesteak, and it doesn't disappoint. Bar service is top notch as well. Definitely recommend... stopping in if you're in the area, nice, chill vibe ???? Read more

Went there with some friends just this past Saturday. Never been there before, impressed with the quality of the food and the... service. I didn't see the tab, because someone else picked it up in our party, but no one had any complaints! Definitelyvisiting again next time I'm down that way.. Read more

Friendly staff and nice atmosphere but the prices are high considering the amount and quality of food given. Wings are pricey... and don?t even come with celery or carrots or anything, like if you?re spending 13$ on wings shouldn?t they come with somethingon the side? Even Buffalo Wild Wings does that at least. Kids meal even is like 10$ and was very minimal, other diners meal wassmall portioned despite the price. Granted I?m pretty sure these are pre inflation prices I don?t even want to know what they?regoing to be once they update menu... love the vibe there and staff is terrific but you just don?t get a lot of bang for yourbuck. Read more

Been coming here for years. While the ownership and decor has changed, the food, drinks and the awesome staff is still there! ... From wings to prime rib, you get a great meal for a reasonable price. Love "THE STICK"! Read more

I was looking for a local place to have a late lunch. I decided to take a "gamble" on the Mystic Islands Casino. I was promptly... seated and given a menu. There was plenty of variety, and a number of beers and other beverages from which to choose. The serverwas prompt, friendly, and helpful. I ordered the prime rib panini which consisted of thinly sliced beef (similar to a cheesesteak), melted cheese, mushrooms, and sauteed onions, and was served with a small cup of au jus for dipping, and a small cup ofcole slaw. Personally, I prefer my cole slaw with a bit more vinegar and slightly less mayo, but it was still good. I alsoordered a side of fries. The sandwich was very flavorful and tender. The fries were fresh and hot. The portions were justright. I enjoyed my meal and will definitely come again when I'm in the area. I would like to try more of the specials andspecialties. Read more