Reviews for Mystic Island Pizza in Little Egg Harbor Township, NJ

The BEST sauce in town. AMAZING customer service. Very pleased with this business... When I first started going here about a... year ago, they rarely ever had Sicilian slices ready to go. I'd have to order a whole pie or have a plain slice and sometimesthey ended up losing my business because I was craving a Sicilian slice THAT bad. Instead of letting that continue... theynoticed the increase of demand for Sicilian slices (even if it was just me asking every other week) and they usually almostALWAYS have my slice ready to pop in the oven when I call. That is what I call service. That is what I call a great business.Way to go Mystic for catering to your customers, listening to their needs, and going above and beyond! Read more

We were in the area and husband wanted pizza. We tried another local place before and did not have a good experience, so when... we found this place through Google he decided to give it a try. We were a little skeptical at first. He went inside to orderslices (plain, white slice and a grandma). I did not eat any as I was not in the mood for pizza, but he is very finicky withhis pizza and he loved them all! We will definitely be back. I think I may try that Pickle pizza after reading other reviews!!We'll see ????. Read more

Mystic Pizza is the best pizza place around! Their pizza is amazing, and I like a lot of their other foods as well. There was... NEVER a time where I had seen anyone in my family disappointed and throwing out a half eaten dish from this place. Mystic Pizzahas great food that is extremely delicious!!! Read more

We're here from out of town and we're looking for pizza but we're sceptical. We called in the order and the woman on the phone... was helpful and friendly. We got an antipasto salad (very good with a delicious piece of bread and a ball of fresh mozzarella),large cheese, and medium sweet chili chicken pickle pizza (just for fun). The pizzas were all around tasty with a nice flavor tothe crust which was cooked just right. The sweet chili chicken pizza was pretty tasty and honestly has me thinking about addingpickles to pizza more often. We'll definitely be back! Read more

Amazing pizza and amazing service! We came in after they closed the dining room and they insisted they serve us anyways. We got... a medium pepperoni pizza and it was very substantial for the price, as well as very good. Highly recommend for anyone in thearea you won?t be disappointed. Read more

Okay.....I know!! Pickles on pizza may not seem like a great idea ... However!! This is Next Level Pizza ... Sweet Chilli... Chicken Pickle Pizza..!!! "With no pizza sauce"!!! Is hands down the best meal in town. Read more

Our pizza from here is usually the best pizza I ever had but the pizza we just got for lunch is soaked in grease,I've never seen... that before... Read more

Amazing place! Known as the Greatest spot on Earth. The kosher dill pickle pizza is to die for. The cashier is super friendly... and very sweet. The owner sings and speaks in the most Beautiful Napolitano accent. Great people great food Read more