Reviews for Paula's Donuts in Tonawanda, NY
Heard this place was known for the Peanut Sticks so I ordered 4 of them. Everything else looked good too but inventory was... getting low, I came in an hour before closing so it was understandable. The Peanut Sticks, my god, they were really really good.The crunch of the peanuts and then the softness inside, amazing food! Read more
We have been at the Tonawanda location twice however they were closed. We finally made it during opening hours and we were not... disappointed. Our biggest hit was the Canoli donut. OMG it was amazing but so many more to try. The store was clean and theservice was outstanding. We went at about 320pm on a Monday so I'm not sure how crazy it gets in the mornings. Read more
Tucked away off one of the main streets is Paula? Donuts. Although everyone mentions Tim Hortons, I decided to try Paula?s. It... did not disappoint! I got a coffee and sausage, egg,and cheese sandwich on a bagel! Well worth it! Read more
Paula?s, I used to love your giant apple fritter, it was such a classic. But what is this? I ordered apple fritter, but this is... NOT an Apple fritter! ?? for whatever donut this is, it?s just ok, too much apple filling and overly sweet and alcohol-ish forsome reason? it made the boring chocolate sour cream donut the highlight of the order? I understand you have a labor shortage,but please stay classic and cool! Read more
Huge donuts made with love! Strawberry shortcake donut was amazing! We will definitely make a special trip to come back.
I love Paula?s Donuts and have been a customer for over ten years. Whenever I cross the border, one of my go-to places is... Paula?s, where I order my favorite, the Frosted Angel Cream. This time, I lived on the edge and preordered specialty donuts:Maple Bacon Cinnamon Roll, Cannoli Donuts, Maple Angel Cream and Cookies and Cream. My freezer is now stocked until I cross theborder again and indulge in these heavenly pleasures. Totally worth the drive from Canada! Read more
Paula's donuts were just okay. There is a lot to choose from. There isn't a shortage of variety. The customer service is very... good. Cashier's are very knowledgeable and courteous. Some of our donuts were hard and didn't taste any better than a gasstation donut. The powdered filled donuts are delicious. I also tried a cheese danish. The cashier warmed it for me and thatmade a huge difference. It was simply too hard straight out of the case. When you opt to dine in store they do serve you offglass plates which I thought was a nice touch. Maybe if some of the donuts were served warm they would taste a lot better.Majority of the ones we tried were pretty hard. They also didn't have a fresh taste to them. Not the worst donuts I've ever had,Just middle of the road okay. Read more
I was craving Paula's Donuts so I grabbed a dozen after work. Although I admit there was sticker shock ($21 for a dozen), I... simply forgot about it after biting into a Pumpkin Spice donut. Life is good... Read more