Reviews for Emilio's Pizza in Toms River, NJ
Love their Pizza. When I visit my parents it's my go to on the checklist for a slice. Eat in or take out is always fresh and... hot. They just don't make pizza like this in other parts of the US. Read more
My wife and I dined here on a Friday evening. I ordered the chicken tortellini soup (tortellini in brodo) for a first course. ... The broth was under seasoned and tasted as if it could be prepackaged. The tortellini tasted freezer burned. My wife hadtortellini alfredo for her entrée and like the soup the pasta had freezer burned flavor. The alfredo sauce was insipid. Myentrée was chicken murphy; the dish was swimming in sauce. The flavor was underwhelming. However, the restaurant comped thepasta dish, so that was appreciated. The waitstaff was very good and was very helpful with our complaint on the dish. All thingsconsidered would not return. Read more
Don't break a nail to go there..it's ok...but on a couple of occasions I seen them pull cheap tricks with portions and then I... seen them tell a senior lady they were out of mushroom pizza as she wanted it from the slices they sell.told her they only hadthe slices of plain and others that were in display...you mean they could not go in the back and put some on the plain slicesthey did have or at least offer it...just disappointing. AND NOT TO MENTION THE TWO SLICES OF HAM ON A HAM AND CHEESE HOGIE...ISENT IT BACK...they think their the best place in the area...Go see for yourself. No two days are alike Read more
Ordered the stuffed shells and could not eat it at all. Way too much salt in everything. Even the shells were overly salty.... Place was clean and service was good. Read more
I ordered a shrimp parm sub for takeout, it was the worse I?ve ever had, I took one bite and spit it out, the fried shrimp... inside was as hard as a rock. I don?t live close by so returning it was not an option, but I will not order from Emilio?s again,old overcooked dry hard shrimp belongs in the garbage! Gross. Read more
04/29/2022: This is my first visit with a guest and me. Dinner for two included soup, salad, two orders of Eggplant Parmigiana,... Broccoli & Garlic then Cheesecake and coffee. Service was prompt & upbeat. Dishes were brought our well spaced in time. Diningarea is bright with LARGE windows. There is ample parking and easy access. I will definitely visit here again. ed Read more
Great food me and my friends enjoyed it I hit my knew on the bar under the table and taht hurt like hell but oh well
Haven't any complaints about the food is always good pizzas are great after 10 save the coupon on top and get a free one. Good... all year. Read more