Reviews for Brooklyn Square Pizza in Toms River, NJ
The pizza is definitely different than I am used to, but I definitely enjoyed it. Fluffy, Crispy and a Very Tasty Sauce.
I went there twice. Very friendly atmosphere and pizza was tasty. The pizza has a Brooklyn taste slightly different than North... Jersey pizza flavor. Good news is it tasted like real pizza vs South Jersey impostors. Bad news is they should toss pizzasthat are burnt..quality control. Pizza is pricey these days so make each piece a good deal. Read more
By far the best pizza in the area. So good that other pizzerias are now copying their specialty pies. I do recommend eating in... as the pie will cool down and it won't be as crisp (steam in box). It's expensive pizza but very memorable. Read more
The classic square pizza is tomato forward, and the crust has a lovely contrast between an uber-crisp bottom and airy dough. The... pizza turned out so much lighter than I was judging from the appearance. The store also sells its own bottled drinks. I had theginger ale and found it refreshing. This pizza is definitely in the running for best I've ever had, and is without a doubt thebest Sicilian I've eaten. Do yourself a favor and visit if you're in the area. And if you aren't, going out of your way to eatthis pizza is time well spent. It's that good. Read more
After waiting over 2 hours for delivery. Had a bone in my chicken parm pizza. Good thing my 4 year old didn't get that piece.... Threw the rest away since I was skeptical if there was additional bones. $26 pie in the garbage. My cold antipasto was putbetween the hot pie and a hot order of meatballs so it was hot antipasto and warm Lettuce and the cheese melted inside the meat.Waste. Every 4 months or so I try to go back and give this place another chance but this is it. I'm not sure if it's just theToms River store or what but never had these problems with Jackson. Maybe its time to concentrate less on social media fame andmore on quality and customer service. Read more
Okay so a single plain slice is $2.75, $1 more with toppings, but i mean sadly this is common now...$16 for a large pie... though... that's a good price while most places are close to $21. Prices aside staff is friendly, place is clean. Pizza rankingis HIGH! Many types of slices available, crust and sauce are excellent, cheese is very good. Overall best in Toms River! Read more
Really good pizza here the upside down was great had great sauce high quality cheese and the dough was crunchy on the outside... and fluffy in the inside it was great and the regular slice was good and loved the sesame seed crust will definitely have itagain!! Read more
Best Sicilian I ever had. Light, crispy the sauce is awesome the pie is not overly cheesy. We ate in