Reviews for The Stubborn Brother Pizza Bar in Toledo, OH

I recommend going to this place. I give this place 4 stars because I was not satisfied with the garlic Romano oven-baked wings.... The flavor is fine, but the texture of the chicken was not. Since the chicken wings are baked with the skin on, the skin feelsslippery when you bite into it. And, it's not crispy. So, skip the wings. I do recommend ordering the twice-baked garlic rolls.They were delicious. The pizza is delicious too. I've tried Rocco's Meat Lovers pizza and it was satisfying. I've also triedGiavanna's White pizza and it was tasty. They also have a great selection of alcoholic beverages as well. So, this is a greatplace to hang out for drinks and pizza. Read more

Not sure what happened to this place we?ve been regulars since they opened. we live in Old Orchard, dine in or carry out made... sure to support during COVID even. This past weekend we received the most disgusting and cold pizza I?ve ever seen, was told bythe Manager ?Andrew? it was our fault for not picking it up on time yet my husband was there within the 30min time frame thewebsite gave us, but he still had to wait for our order to be complete and wait on the sub we ordered. Andrew could only?discount? our pizza couldn?t tell me how much for a 30 dollar pizza and a Mancy family restaurant am digusted by the pizza andservice. The pizza picture is the pizza we received ?the rocket? Read more

Found another place that streams the UT Rocket games when they are out of town!!! Daughter loved the wedge salad. Friend had the... Italian beef and raved about it. I've had multiple things there and have no complaints on anything. The antipasto is one of myfavorites. Daughter's Godfather is from New York and says that their thick crust is as close to Sicilian style that he's hadanywhere. Read more

This was my husband and I?s first time eating here. We were looking for a NY style pizza without having to drive the 8 hours to... NY to get it. The restaurant itself was nice. I loved the industrial vibe. When we walked in, there were maybe 3 people insideeating or waiting to eat. There only appeared to be one server/bartender. We sat ourselves and was greeted by the femaleserver/bartender to let us know our server would be with us soon. Another server approached our table asking about drinks &appetizers. We put in our order & waited. We ordered the garlic rolls as an appetizer. They came out and looked delicioushowever they were barely cooked & cold. I don?t know about you but we like a crispy garlic bread. We hoped this wasn?t going tobe how the pizza would come out. Our pizza finally emerged & looked excellent! The pizza was crispy, light sauce, pepperoni &cheese. It was the complete opposite of the garlic rolls! Super yummy! All in all I?d say the pizza was great. Just what we werelooking for. The garlic rolls not so much. We don?t live far from Toledo but I wouldn?t make the drive just for this pizza butif you?re in the area it?s worth stopping by. Read more

Visited here with my coworkers a few weeks ago. The drinks were great and I was surprised how good the pizza and wings were.... Loved the environment as well. We had a pretty large party and the service was great too. I would definitely visit again. Onlynegative, the pizza did not reheat well the next day. Read more

I ordered the onion and pepper pizza slice and they took 15 minutes to bring it out. The pizza was cold as if they took it out... of the fridge. Would not recommend. Read more

Delicious pizza!!! Thin crust pizza at it's finest! The sauce is savory and the crust has a good crunch to it! Highly... satisfied and plan on many more visits!!! Read more

WOW! What a amazing pizza! We got this pizza delivered and it was way better than we were expecting. It had the perfect amount... of cheese/sauce/toppings with some fresh herbs sprinkled on top. The garlic bread was okay but the pizza will definitely bringback my business. I can't wait to try the dine-in experience next time! Highly recommend to any pizza connoisseurs out there! Read more