Reviews for Nancy's Pizzeria in Tinley Park, IL
Order pizzas for years, always wonder if the pizzas were pre made we would always get them in about 30 minutes when told 45 to... an hour. The last time the peppers and onions weren?t cooked and the cheese was thrown on top and barely melted and the pizza asa whole was jus warm. Wrote the main office, they assured me that the pizzas are all made to order and completely baked. Theyalso said they would forward on my email. Never heard from them. Domino?s would make a better pizza. Wont be back Nancy?s ofTinley Park. Bad pizza bad business!! Read more
Truly the best stuffed pizza in Chicago. Better than Giordano's by 100? with a legitimate cheese pull that I never seen at... Giordano's restaurant or at home. Read more
Been enjoying Nancy's for years. Ordered a thin crust large pepperoni which was great. Also ordered the godfather as I have over... the years. Disappointed. The beef very salty..hardly any mozzarella cheese on it..it usually was on top..not this time..garlicbread only lightly baked and they dipped it in gravy which they never did before. So it was a salty cheese less soggy sandwich.Not good. Then we ordered waffle fries which weren't cooked through. They don't sell their onion rings which were delicious.We'll stick with the pizza only. Just not what we expected. Read more
We love this place. We get the godmother sandwiches regularly and they are the best. If you like chicken parmigiana sandwiches... then you will love these. We don?t even bother with other places because they will disappoint after these. The garlic bread isbuttery and crispy and complement the chicken so well. The service is excellent as well. It is nice to know our business isappreciated. Read more
I love their pizza, thick or thin. I love their service too they're always fast and friendly. Issues resolved in a previous... order without any push back. Try the Italian beef sandwich it's great! I'm not in delivery area but if I crave pizza I go toNancy's in Tinley. 11 stars Read more
Pizza is good. Been hear allot good things from people around... Very Good for the price of what you get
I actually don't really like deep dish pizza because of the dough to topping ratio (I'm a thin crust and brick oven pizza kind... of girl) but my boyfriend loves it so of course we had to get some while in Tinley Park. I give Nancy's 2 thumbs up! We got the1.5" cheese pizza and I think they bake the cheese into the dough... I don't know how they do what they do but it was so good!!!The dough tasted really good (reminded me of a little of the crust on Pizza Hut's personal pan pizza) and it wasn't too much forthe amount of cheese. I also love cheese so the ooey gooey cheesy goodness of this pizza was perfection. Read more
This is my go to pizza place. Stuffed pizza is the best, thin crust is also the best around