Reviews for Cole's Cakery in Tifton, GA
Cole's Cakery has the best cupcakes in town. We haven't tried any that we don't like, but the Reese's and Boston Cream Pie are... some of our favorites. Plus they rotate in some seasonal flavors that never disappoint. Kids love the pink lemonade one. Wouldpost pictures but they usually don't last long enough to get one. In addition to the cupcakes they have great jalapeno pimentocheese and chicken salad. The pimento cheese makes for awesome grilled cheese sandwiches. Staff are great and it seems like theyknow everyone who walks in. You really get the small-town feel when stopping by. 6 stars. Read more
I have tried several bakeries since we moved to Tifton. This is the best bakery so far that we have visited. ???? My family... calls me ? The food critic ? if I say that it?s good, then it?s good! I took my daughters here on their birthday and they lovedthe cupcakes! I had the red velvet and turtle cupcakes! Yummmmy! Read more
Will never buy a cake from anywhere else again! Cole's will make anything you ask for, in a timely manner, and is beyond... delicious!!! They have plenty of treats to choose from. They are always coming up with new ideas. Also yummy chicken salad,pimento cheese and pasta salads! And the ice cream stuffed cupcakes are to die for. We love Cole's!!! Read more
I don't even know where to begin... The cake is AMAZING, but I think the people are even better. We had cake and cupcakes done... for our wedding. We live an hour away, and they delivered. I was slightly unorganized in my cake toppers/decorations, and madesome last minute decisions. I messaged them the day before and asked if I left a topper and some fake flowers if they could makesomething up... Well, I remember thinking it was pretty the day of, but it is all kind of a blur. I just got my photos back, andlet me tell you... they worked MAGIC with the stuff I left for then and it was PERFECT. It also tasted AMAZING!! I am sograteful for their flexibility. If you are considering them, just do it. Read more
The owners and workers are extremely friendly and personable! They make really good food and really put time and effort into it.... Their cakes are incredible. You will not be disappointed by eating at Cole?s Cakery! It?s a must try in Tifton, GA. Read more
I called this bakery to order a homemade cake having never done any business with them before, in fact I live several hours... north of Tifton. Well I want everyone to know they delivered, it was a wonderful cake and they did exactly what I asked them todo, "make me a real homemade carrot cake". The price was reasonable too. They even agreed to accommodate me for an early opentime so we could pick it up at a time that fit our schedule. I give them 5 stars and recommend to everyone to visit this place.And, don't let your mamma's do so much work on Thanksgiving, order a nice cake from Cole's, you won't be disappointed! Read more
These are the best people ever. Their custom cakes are delicious and beautiful. If you need any desserts for ANY occasion I... would highly recommend Cole's Cakery! They did my wedding cake. They made the experience personal and perfect. Everyone wantedto know who made the cakes because they were both delicious and beautiful! Morale to the story use Cole's Cakery for everythingthey're great people with a great service! Read more
We have purchased cupcakes from this establishment in the past and I can admit they were very good. My fiance recently purchased... a cake for my birthday. The cake was decorated well.but was extremely DRY! I was so disappointed and embarrassed because I hadbeen giving high compliments on the bakery. Buyers please beware. Read more