Reviews for Rick's New York Pizza of Tarpon Springs in Tarpon Springs, FL

We ordered a medium meat lovers pizza, which was loaded with toppings and more than enough for 2 average eaters. We were both... hoping for a bit more sauce because it was a little dry, but it tasted very good. The pizza was ready on time and service wasvery friendly. You can not order as a guest online because the phone number spot requires too many digits, which I brought tothe employee's attention when I picked up, but she didn't seem too interested. They have a huge menu and we will definitely goback to try some of their meal options. Read more

Hands down this is THE BEST pizza in ALL of Florida. My wife and I come here all the way from St. Pete. We always order a ton of... pizza and other Italian dishes so we can have left overs. Staff are great also. It is really hard to distinguish this pizza fromone from NY. I don?t understand some of the negative reviewers. Those people MUST be used to eating garbage pizza and don?t knowwhat good pizza is. Let them eat garbage. As for me and my house, we will eat at Ricks. Try it and see if I?m lying. Read more

Have ordered their pizza many many times and it's the best! Today, dined in at the restaurant for the first time. This is the... best Italian food I've found in this area. The sauce tasted like Nonna's and the portion of lasagna was more than generous. Ifyou are a garlic fan, get the garlic knots as well. You can't go wrong with anything at Rick's NY Pizza! If you're lucky,Dominic will serve you. Delicious food, good service, good prices and a charming server....what more could you want? Read more

Wanted to try something new and they had a cheesesteak pizza so I ordered it and when I got home it was so dissapointing. Not... much flavor let alone cheesesteak on it. More onions than anything and very little peppers or mushrooms. Read more

I'm from Connecticut recently moved to Florida. Up there we have some of the best pizza you would ever imagine. However down... here it's hard to find. I've been looking for a good spot and I heard a recommendation for this place. The owners were reallynice and even opened the box and said "what do you think about this?" I have a feeling they saw my area code and knew what I waslooking for. It did not disappoint. Very delicious pizza. This will be my spot. Read more

Rick?s is our go to pizza place. It helped us get thru the Covid experience and we?d like to think we helped their business... survive it. Besides the tasty food, Rick?s is like home but a big part of that is Donna. She is a customer service dynamo andkeeps the place humming. Thank you, Donna, for your hard work in making Kevin?s birthday party a success and for your excellentservice whenever we stop in! Whoever is making the pizza lately?it?s extra yummy! Keep it comin! Read more

Enjoyed my requisite slice of cheese pizza which has become my barometer for rating any pizzeria that markets itself as "NYC... style." To this end, it was definitely NYC style foldable - plus flavorful enough to satisfy my craving - though because it wasa tad dry and slightly overcooked, I deducted 1 star. I did nonetheless enjoy it and I really appreciated the chill atmosphereand friendly staff after a rough morning at the ortho! ???? Read more

First time in this wonderful restaurant, Hailey was our server, she is fairly new but took care of us well. It was busy and she... was flying around restaurant. We are staying at the Quality Inn just behind this restaurant. Girlfriend was reading off items onmenu so she made the choice of eating here. If your in the area or staying this is must try. They have tablets for menu's whichis a super smart idea, for a starter We had "Rick's Sampler" it was a good choice a little bit of 4 items, next we had a saladand large chucks of cheese in the blue cheese dressing, very nice, Girlfriend had Baked Ravioli which she had Alfredo Sauce puton top, I had the Eggplant Rollatine. Both was very good, girlfriend never had eggplant so it was a new one for her. Lastly Ilove desserts and so we got 4 different kinds. Skyscraper Red Velvet Cake, Cannoli, Napolean, and of course the famous Tiramisu.Now my all time favorite is the Tiramisu and I have to say thank you Rick for making a great Tiramisu, it's been a long timesince I have had one this good and Thank you Hailey for taking so well care of us on our visit! We will be back Read more