Reviews for Plum Tomato Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria in Tarpon Springs, FL

The food was very good, however I was overcharged and the manager refused to fix the price on my bill. The menu has one price... but was charge another price. I asked them to show me how they got to that price and they could not answer that. Therefore, Iwill not go back there again since they cannot be honest. Read more

Best pizza and calzones in town! They have great meals too. This definitely a place worth multiple visits to try everything they... offer. Read more

I ordered dinner from here a few nights ago, and I have been thinking about it ever since. The Bolgenese sauce was so flavorful... with hints of garlic, and olive oil. The Alfredo was equal parts buttery, and cheesy! Portions were huge, so count on leftoversunless your sharing. Might just order again tonight.....???? Read more

Very good food, large portions and friendly staff. Will definitely be back.

Nice family run Italian restaurant in a small retail strip center. Foods seem to all be fresh and made to order. The lasagna... had a nice sauce but seemed overcooked with the noodle texture and the char on the meat. The Alfredo sauce is very heavy withfresh cheese and cream. So be prepared for a heavy homemade Alfredo, a plus if that's what you seek but for me was too heavy.The alla Vodka sauce provides a better balance of flavor and eliminates the extreme heaviness of the Alfredo, yet is still onthe heavy side. The flavor profile on the alla vodka also lacked the little zing and boldness I seek, so some extra oregano andsome crushed pepper was added by me. Overall this place is worth a visit since while just an okay place by my taste buds. Icould also see how someone could rate this establishment both lower or higher than me. Read more

Best pizza around, try the vodka fries ???? or a glass of wine with your pizza . Fresh ingredients really makes a difference.... You can watch them make your food and you can see how clean the kitchen is. Makes me and the family feel safer. Great staff,Melissa, Dawn and GG always on top of things..... never an empty glass! ???? Read more

THE BEST PIZZA IN TAMPA! New York style crust that?s thin and crispy! I love love love this place! The space is very small, but... it?s a great place to try if you haven?t yet! I?ve never ordered a pasta dish, but the bowls are HUGE and look/smell amazing! Ifi didn?t love the pizza so much i?d definitely try a different dish! Read more

Use to be my favorite pizza place a few years back. The dough and sauce were amazing with the freshest toppings. Now? I?m not... sure what changed, but, if you like cardboard pizza, then it?s for you. The carry out and delivery is always a minimum of anhour wait. And like I said.....tasteless cardboard. Even got garlic knots to try.....they tasted like they?d been setting out onthe counter for a week. The sauce with them was so bland I wouldn?t have guessed what it was without looking. I give them a tryevery year to see if they?ve improved......I?m over it! Read more