Reviews for Jimmy's Neighborhood Restaurant in Tarpon Springs, FL

What an amazing experience. Just tried Jimmy's for the first time and I am so impressed. The food was delicious and the service... was really good. We tried the calamari, and pizza and pasta. Everything was delicious and we just loved it. Thank you Jimmy andstaff for the great dinner. Read more

We haven?t been here in many years. The food was very good. Service was good. The restaurant is very clean. They have a wide... selection on their menu for all the picky eaters such as my kids who can never agree on the same thing. We had the garlic breadfor an appetizer. I split the pizza with one daughter as my other daughter had the shrimp pasta. We did have leftovers thereforethe portions to say the least are rather big. Read more

This place is a 10! My son and I went to Tarpon Springs and the Sponge Docks were a madhouse. We Googled nearby restaurants and... located Jimmy's. The restaurant was clean, well run, and had a neighborhood feel. The food was OUTSTANDING - the mussels wereexceptional, the grilled octopus was the best I'd ever had, and the gyro was fantastic. And to top it off, this place is 3minutes from Sunset Park if you want to catch a beautiful Florida sunset after dinner. All around, Jimmy's NeighborhoodRestaurant is fantastic and we can't wait to go there again to try other items from the menu. Read more

So far the spot hasn't dissapoint.. I ordered the meat lovers pizza and it did not dissapoint, it was good!!! Also had the ... Spaghetti and meatballs loved it. Def would recommend and I will continue to order. Read more

Nice outdoor seating. Delicious gyro. We loved the fish appetizer. Large portion for meals. Will definitely return if we?re ever... back in town. Read more

Pleasantly surprised! Found it on Google Maps and the menu and pics (and octopus) looked great so we decided to give it a try. ... Soooo glad we did! Diner-like atmosphere but the food and service is AMAZING! Being first-timers, you're not sure what to expectwhen you walk in to an out-of-the-way place you figure is mostly locals, but the friendliness of the staff made us feel as if wewere regulars ourselves (we've already added it to our definitely-return list). We had the grilled octopus (REALLY good andcooked perfectly) and the belly clams, which were so clammy and a HUGE order (and the best tartar sauce around)! And theirlemon potatoes were AWESOME! Nowhere have they been as lemony as here! Thank you to the entire staff, front and back! Very welldone Jimmy's! We'll be back soon! Read more

Service was exceptional, great menu, food is always delicious, cooked perfect, and plentiful portions. I had the smelts... appetizer....absolutely scrumptious!!! The grouper Florentine was the best!! Read more

Excellent food and service at Jimmy?s! We ate there the other night and Autumn was an absolute gem. This is one of the best... restaurants in Tarpon Springs for quality Italian American and Greek dishes. Their saganaki- flaming Greek halloumi cheese isthe best I?ve eaten in Tarpon Springs. I highly recommend their homemade lasagna as it?s absolutely divine and a great valuedish. It?s impossible to make a better lasagna. I also recommend their homemade cheesecake with raspberry purée for dessert asit?s also excellent. Fellow customers were raving to us about the pizzas, which are also very popular as Jimmy?s makes the doughin house. Ask for recommendations and select what?s made in house, as it?s prepared with love. I can?t wait to return to tryone of their delicious looking pizzas! Read more