Reviews for Anthony's New York Style Pizza in Tampa, FL
First time I had it, it was very good. I asked them to not put spices on before cooking and it appears they still add oregano.... It is too heavy and we couldn't eat it.... I'll try it one more time, but watch too see if they add any spice before they backthe pie Read more
Delicious pizza, 28? is enough for a party of 8 people. Well recommend
I used to live in Tampa and I worked in Carrollwood. If I had known this place existed years ago, it would've changed my life... way sooner. This pizza made me feel like a teenage mutant ninja turtle (in an incredible way) I ordered 2 slices of cheese and aCaesar salad to go. Had I known that one single slice would be the size of my head, I probably would've only gotten one. I was alittle surprised at the price of $5 per slice but holy cow now I know why. The pizza was delicious, NY style and held up whenyou folded it to eat it even though it was HUGE. Wish I wasn't leaving town on Monday so I could try more stuff on the menu.Salad was also good but holy cannoli that pizza was perfection. Exactly what I was wanting while visiting my old stompinggrounds. Pennsylvania may be closer to NY but, no lie, FL has lots of incredible options for NY pizza. I would absolutely notmiss trying this one though. Definitely worth it. Read more
We ordered here for the 1st time to try them out. We got a large alfredo pizza, large hawaiian pizza, 3 large meat balls and... cheese sticks. The cheese sticks were hard like they left it under the heat lamp for too long. The meatballs were small and notworth the $2 per meatball. As for the pizza we have attached some pictures. As you can see all the sauce and toppings slide toone corner of the box. It was not worth the $70 price tag. We will not order from here again. Read more
Omg my lunch was more like a dinner! Super tasty eggplant parmigiana! The portion was big! Ate some than & saved the rest for... later! Read more
I like the italian sub here when the right person makes it. I'm trying the pizza again after a long time. Mixed feelings, the... pizza tastes great, nice cheese, great sauce and the toppings were very good. No char to the crust loses a star from me, it waschewey and at times gooey. They have a tradional oven so why no char? Is oven temp too low or pizza removed from the oven tooearly? Do I need to request it? When I know, you'll know. The place looks a little dumpy, a cleaning crew and someorganizational skills are in order. If you like a chewy crust, this is your spot. Read more
This place is utterly horrible. I am sorry that I even considered ordering from here before reading the reviews. I came across... this place as ' Tampa Pasta Bar ' on UberEats and considering my children and I love pasta, I decided to give this place atry. I've attached pictures of the two entrees I ordered totaling $40. One is a chicken parmigiana with no cheese for allergyreasons. The second is supposed to be pasta with clam sauce. The entrees look absolutely nothing like the pictures I saw onUberEats, the QUANTITY AND QUALITY is horrendous! Everything is bland and has ZERO taste. The pasta for both entrees are dry,they did not put any clam sauce, it looks like a drop of something was placed in the middle and about 3/4 pieces of meat thatresemble clam. I feel sorry that my son has to attempt to eat this, I will be buying him something else. You'd be better offbuying McDonalds than ordering from here. Zero Stars. Read more
I love pizza and it passed the test. Very good (crispy crust) not floppy. You can dine in or carry out. Fast service. Anthony's... has a tv to watch sports as well. Staff was very friendly. They also have pizza and chicken wings specials(be sure to askabout them). Read more