Menu for Five Star Pizza in Tallahassee, FL

This pizza took me back to my childhood so I had a nostalgic moment when taking the first bite! It reminded me of how Chuck E.... Cheese pizza use to taste back in the 90s when everyone was talking about it and ordering it out like crazy too! So good which Icould give you all 10 stars ?? I got the specialty pepperoni ?something? but it?s the one with extra pepperoni and cheese with aorder of cinnamon rolls which was oh so good and made with fresh dough OMG!!! My new pizza spot DEFINITELY?.update: tryreheating it the next day in the oven on 350 for 10-15 minutes bc it tastes just how I picked it up!!! ???????????????? Read more

I've been coming here since their .99 cent delivery. When they first opened this was my favorite place. I would rave about this... place and referred MANY people to this establishment as it's better than your normal pizza chains .Recently ordering food I'venoticed the service and quality has been decreasing. My final straw was last night ordering wings and getting Food poisoningfrom the wings. I woke up at 5am and was in the bathroom nonstop throwing up. This was the first time I've gotten sick fromthem, normally I have to bake the wings at home because I always ask for them to make them extra extra crispy but they told methey're not allowed to do that and it always look undercooked. I called today to tell a manager about getting sick from thewings and all i got was an apology and thay there's nothing they could do. I paid $25 to get sick and now they've lost a loyalcustomer. Now I need a new pizza place to give my money to. -------------- In response to the owner: I called at 11:15 thismorning and spoke to a man who said he was a manager. I have no reason to lie.. I've also had multiple employees who told me permanagement and the owner thay they are not allow to make the wings extra crispy. I should've taken a picture of my wings sinceI'm now lying about even calling the store this morning which I did. Read more

I love this hidden gem. I do not want people to realize how great they are so I can keep them to myself and hope that they never... become like all the rest. They have the best customer service to go along with their amazing pizza and business hours. Just liketheir pizza box says, "Best pizza & Best value." True & True! Keep up the great work guys! Read more

First time trying and they did not disappoint! Went for their Pizza, Rolls and Wings special. Great price for the amount of... food. We ordered 16" Pepperoni Pizza, Garlic Rolls, and Garlic Parmesan Wings. Didn't realize until ordering that they came withsauces for the rolls and wings. Happy bonus since most places charge extra for sauces. Yall the flavors were on point, dough andRolls were fluffy, and they didn't skimp on the wings! I think we found a new fav... Read more

I started working there in January of 2019. It was under different ownership at the time but the owner was great to work with.... When he sold it to the new owner. I have really loved working for him and his girlfriend. They are not bosses. They are likefamily to me. The pizza there is absolutely amazing and my family love the BBQ chicken with mushrooms and minced garlic added toit. Read more